Recent Posts
Business, News
Business, News
Connect with:
Tuesday / July 15.
  • No products in the cart.
SECTION
logo
mobile-logo
HomeStandard Blog Whole Post (Page 107)
Business, News, Sports

Bob Mackin

The Canadian Olympic Committee’s proposal for another Vancouver Winter Olympics in 2030 contains no cost estimate and officials say wait until the middle of summer for details.

Vancouver 2030 proposed venues map (COC)

“It’s quite a complex calculation, and so we’ll just provide a briefing on that in July,” said Mary Conibear, managing director of Games operations for Vancouver 2010. She is part of the team behind the 26-page, Games Engagement draft hosting concept released June 14 at the Squamish-Lil’wat Cultural Centre. 

July is when the COC and leaders of the Four Host First Nations (FHFN) want City of Vancouver and Resort Municipality of Whistler councils to support crafting a formal proposal to the International Olympic Committee. Salt Lake City, the 2002 host, and Sapporo, Japan, the 1972 host are also pondering bids. The IOC wants to choose the 2030 host by the time it meets in Mumbai at the end of May 2023. 

The COC, the de facto bid committee, has discouraged all six parties from holding a referendum this year, for fear it would ruin the chance for “targeted dialogue” negotiations with the IOC. 

“We still haven’t seen the books from 2010,” said Coun. Colleen Hardwick, the mayoral candidate for TEAM for a Liveable Vancouver. “Most concerning is the democratic deficit, despite the desire to have a vote that the city will press ahead.”

In April, Hardwick unsuccessfully proposed adding a yes or no question on the 2030 bid to the Oct. 15 civic election ballot, noting that 64% of voters passed a 2003 plebiscite before the IOC chose Vancouver to host the 2010 Olympics and Paralympics. 

No one else on city council seconded her motion. Hardwick is also concerned because board minutes and financial ledgers from the Vancouver 2010 organizing committee (VANOC) are locked from public view until October 2025.

Vancouver 2030 bid logo

“We do not move forward without one another,” said feasibility team member Tewanee Joseph, who was the FHFN executive director in 2010. “That’s what’s important when we talk about indigenous values and processes.”

One of the councillors who did not support Hardwick’s motion was COPE Coun. Jean Swanson. The Downtown Eastside anti-poverty activist who organized protests against the 2010 Games is now having second thoughts. 

“The Host Nations still need to discuss with their folks and we need more details on [costs],” Swanson said. “I am torn on this one cause want to support [Musqueam, Squamish and Tsleil-Waututh first nations], but also am aware of issues with past Olympics such as land cost escalation, massive expenditure on things with no lasting value like security, police activity in DTES.”

The 2030 bid does not have support from the provincial government, which recently announced the $1 billion Royal B.C. Museum project for 2030 and is hoping FIFA chooses Vancouver on June 16 to host up to five matches in the 2026 World Cup. That could cost $260 million. 

Should the councils continue with the bid, the COC plans to make formal proposals to the federal Liberal and B.C. NDP treasury boards this fall.

Last December, Vancouver, Whistler and the reunited FHFN agreed to explore a bid. In February, the COC began the feasibility study. The concept plan said the 2030 Olympics would run Feb. 8-24, 2030 and the Paralympics from March 8-17, 2030. 

In May, theBreaker.news revealed the proposed venues. Most 2010 venues would reprise their roles, except snowboarding and freestyle skiing would go to Sun Peaks near Kamloops, curling at the Agrodome, and the new big air skiing and snowboarding events on a temporary ramp at Hastings Racecourse. The latter would be the biggest sporting venue of the Games, by spectator capacity, with room for 20,000 people. 

Whereas False Creek was the focal point in 2010, it would be Hastings Park in 2030 with nightly medal awards concerts at the PNE Amphitheatre, the official merchandise superstore, a daytime live site, cultural village and sponsor pavilions.  

Canadian Olympic Committee president Tricia Smith (left) and Four Host First Nations executive director Tewanee Joseph (second from left) at the Dec. 10 bid exploration announcement (Twitter/Tewanee Joseph)

Tim Gayda, the vice-president of sport for VANOC, said it would be the “place to go even if you don’t have a ticket to go into see an event.”

“We really see Hastings Park as a real centrepiece for our games,” said Gayda, the 2030 feasibility team’s master planner.

A new Vancouver Olympic Village would be built at either the Jericho Lands or Heather Lands, both co-owned by MST Development.

West Vancouver’s Cypress turned into a weather nightmare for organizers in 2010, so they’re looking 400 kilometres away to Sun Peaks. Gayda said all six courses for freestyle skiing and snowboarding would fit in two stadiums at the resort near Kamloops, which boasts a north-facing slope. 

“It was one of those mountains that we were able to find everything that we wanted,” Gayda said. 

The bid’s Indigenous-led strategy has not been fully defined to the satisfaction of staff at the two municipal governments involved. Joseph, who chairs the Squamish Nation’s Nch’kay, the Squamish Nation’s economic development agency, called the 2030 bid model “co-leadership” and said it would involve governance, planning and hosting policies that correspond with recommendations of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. 

The Games Engagement document also talks of 2030 being the first Games to be “climate positive,” but it does not detail how that can achieved when the Olympics always rely on international air travel and inter-city buses to shuttle athletes, media, workers and spectators around the region. The document does not include any long-range forecast for inventory of electric vehicles or supply of lesser-polluting jet fuel.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

0 Comments

Bob Mackin The Canadian Olympic Committee’s proposal

Business, News, Sports

Bob Mackin

The Canadian Olympic Committee has privately warned partners exploring the Vancouver 2030 Winter Olympics bid that the International Olympic Committee will walk away if any of them hold a referendum before next January. 

The COC released its 2030 Games concept plan in Whistler on June 14. City of Vancouver, Resort Municipality of Whistler and the Four Host First Nations are expected to each decide whether to proceed with the bid in July.

Vancouver Mayor Kennedy Stewart on Dec. 10 (City of Vancouver)

But sources say that a referendum is heavily discouraged because the COC, which is acting as the de facto bid committee, told the six councils that it would ruin the COC’s potential negotiations with the IOC under the new “targeted dialogue” method of awarding the Games.

In April, Coun. Colleen Hardwick unsuccessfully proposed a yes or no question about the 2030 bid for Vancouver’s Oct. 15 civic election ballot. No one else on city council seconded the motion.

Neither the IOC nor COC have responded for comment. The 2002 host, Salt Lake City, and the 1972 host, Sapporo, Japan, are preparing formal bids. Summer 1992 host Barcelona is also considering. The 2030 host city is expected to be announced when the IOC meets in Mumbai next May.

A Portland, Ore. political science professor and author of several books on the politics and economics of the Olympics said the IOC suffers a “democracy deficit.”

“The International Olympic Committee likes to tell the prospective cities for the Olympics, that the Olympics are going to be this really big deal when you get them,” said Jules Boykoff of Pacific University. “And yet, they’re apparently not big enough of a deal to let everyday people in the Olympic city or the Olympic province get a chance to actually vote and have their say.”

In 2019, the IOC studied whether cities should hold a referendum before they become official hosting candidates, but stopped short of making it a requirement. 

“So it’s a total U-turn from that position,” Boykoff said. “Of course, at that time, what we were seeing was this spate of cities staying ‘no thank-you’ to the Olympics, some dozen or so cities between 2013 and 2018.”

Jules Boykoff (Brian Lee)

One of those was Calgary, which gave up on a 2026 bid after more than 56% of voters in the 1988 host city said no in a plebiscite. 

When COPE’s Larry Campbell won the Vancouver mayoralty in 2002, he promised to hold a plebiscite on Vancouver’s 2010 bid. It passed with support of 64% of voters in February 2003. Four months later, the IOC chose Vancouver as the 2010 host.  

Many questions remain about the 2010 Games, which may have cost up to $8 billion including necessary transportation infrastructure. The biggest item was the RCMP-led security operation at nearly $1 billion. The Vancouver 2010 organizing committee (VANOC) never held a public meeting and said in 2014, when it wound down two years late, that it broke-even on a $1.9 billion operating budget. B.C.’s auditor general did not conduct a post-Games audit, VANOC was incorporated beyond reach of the freedom of information law and its files were transferred to the City of Vancouver Archives with restrictions. The public is not allowed to see the board minutes and financials until fall 2025. 

Boykoff said the IOC’s resistance to a 2030 referendum has a lot to do with Vancouverites being more sophisticated than they were in 2003 and because of the many post-Games social, economic and environmental challenges. 

“I view what happened before, during and even after the Vancouver Olympics of 2010 as part of this crucial pivot point, where the general population of the world is becoming more informed about some of those downsides of the Olympics, the negative externalities, the opportunity cost,” Boykoff said. 

The COC’s 2030 Games concept will include its proposed venues list, which Glacier already revealed in May. Most 2010 venues would reprise their roles, except snowboarding and freestyle skiing is proposed for Sun Peaks near Kamloops (instead of Cypress Mountain), curling would be at the Agrodome (instead of Hillcrest Community Centre), the new big air skiing and snowboarding events on a temporary ramp at Hastings Racecourse and nightly medals awards concerts at the PNE Amphitheatre (instead of B.C. Place Stadium). A new Olympic Village would be built at either the Jericho Lands or Heather Lands, both co-owned by three of the four host first nations, the Musqueam, Squamish and Tsleil-Waututh.

Though the bid has been touted as “Indigneous-led,” sources say that has not actually been defined. Every first nation and municipality involved would need to go one step beyond a memorandum of understanding with a legally-binding multiparty agreement that spells-out details of hosting rights and responsibilities. The number of signatories could be as high as 17 and could take the rest of the year to negotiate.

Snowboarding at Sun Peaks near Kamloops (Sun Peaks Resort)

The B.C. NDP government said in May that it has not agreed to support the bid, leaving the municipalities and first nations on their own for now. If the bid proceeds after July, sources say the COC plans to make formal proposals this fall to treasury boards in Victoria and Ottawa. Federal policy says it will fund up to 35% of a major event, but it is up to the host province to be the guarantor. For 2010, the B.C. government also diverted resources from healthcare and education budgets and made BC Hydro, B.C. Lottery Corporation and ICBC sponsors, suppliers and even providers of free labour.

The NDP has expressed its two major tourism and event priorities so far: The $1 billion rebuild of the Royal B.C. Museum by 2030 and the 2026 FIFA World Cup. 

On June 16, Vancouver is expected to be named as host of up to five World Cup matches, along with Toronto. The total cost to taxpayers could be $550 million. 

Staff at 12th and Cambie already have a busy major event schedule. Vancouver’s Formula E race was scheduled for July 2, but cancelled due to lack of permits. It could happen in 2023. Meanwhile, Vancouver is expected to host the Grey Cup in 2024, before Prince Harry’s Invictus Games for wounded military veterans in early 2025. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

0 Comments

Bob Mackin The Canadian Olympic Committee has

Business, News

Bob Mackin

The BC Liberal Party says Kevin Falcon’s late disclosure that his winning leadership campaign overspent by almost $500,000 didn’t break the rules. 

On June 9, Elections BC released Falcon’s campaign finance report that showed it cost $1.078 million to win the race on Feb. 5. Falcon’s biggest line item was $519,396.40 for professional services, followed by $282,002.27 for staff expenses, GST, bad debt and net Liberal Party expenditures and $106,866.38 for social functions. The report does not name suppliers.

Kevin Falcon and BC Liberal leadership candidates except Val Litwin (BC Liberals/Facebook)

The Leadership Election Organizing Committee (LEOC) February 2021 rules included a $600,000 limit on contestant expenses and requirements to meet both party and Elections BC deadlines for campaign financing reports. The party threatened fines of up to $50,000 or disqualification for non-compliance.  

In a prepared statement on June 10, the party’s communications director, David Wasyluk, said Falcon missed the original May 5 deadline because his financial agent was out of the country. Elections BC fined him $500 and granted an extension to June 6.

“The Falcon campaign has provided the party with a detailed breakdown of its expenses, and those expenses have been thoroughly reviewed and audited by party staff,” Wasyluk said. “The BC Liberal Party is confident that the Falcon campaign followed all appropriate guidelines and that their spending did not violate the leadership election rules.”

The statement said various costs are not considered expenses subject to the party’s limit, but are still required to be reported, such as fundraising costs, legal or accounting required to comply with the Election Act, personal expenses and fees related to the leadership contest. 

Wasyluk did not provide a breakdown of Falcon costs that the party considers to be compliant with the leadership contest rules. 

Falcon’s report did not show any cost of fundraising functions on the Elections BC summary of leadership contestant expenses page, but it showed accounting and audit cost $16,424.71 and Falcon’s personal expenses were $26,288.75. The $519,396.40 professional services sum does not indicate how much went to legal fees. 

The summary of expenses shows a crossed-out total $3,234,660.96 below the figure of $1,078,220.32. Falcon’s independent auditor, David Pel, blamed a software glitch. “Every time we made a change and posted the change, it doubled up on the number,” Pel said.

Falcon did not respond to interview requests. Neither did outgoing party president Cameron Stolz or LEOC co-chairs Colin Hansen and Roxanne Helme. 

Falcon’s campaign took in $923,576.18, including $816,796.18 in direct donations and the rest in transfers from the central party. As of Feb. 15, Falcon’s leadership campaign owed $100,000 in loans to RBC at a 2.95% interest rate. 

Kevin Falcon enters the Wall Centre ballroom on Feb. 5 (BC Liberals/Facebook)

He won the Feb. 5 phone and online election on the fifth ballot with 52.19% of weighted votes over runner-up Ellis Ross, the Skeena MLA who had 33.65%. 

The race was held under a cloud of controversy as Falcon’s six opponents complained about thousands of fraudulent memberships sold by Falcon’s team. A B.C. Supreme Court judge rejected a party member’s petition that aimed to delay the release of results by 15 days in order to investigate the allegations.

North Vancouver-resident Falcon handily won an April 30 by-election in Vancouver-Quilchena to fill the seat vacated by ex-leader Andrew Wilkinson. Falcon was sworn-in and took his seat in the Legislature on May 16.

The highlight of the party’s Penticton convention last weekend was the decision to study a complete renaming and rebranding of the party before the 2024 provincial election.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

0 Comments

Bob Mackin The BC Liberal Party says

Business, News

Bob Mackin

Lawyers for two organizers of a protest group that resumed blockading B.C. highways and bridges on June 13 say their clients are not guilty of mischief from an October protest in Richmond and want to stand trial.

Muhammad Zain Ul Haq (left) and Timothy Christopher Brazier of Eco Mobilization Canada, dba Save Old Growth (SOG/YouTube)

Muhammad Zain Ul Haq and Timothy Christopher Brazier were among 18 people arrested Oct. 25, 2021 when Extinction Rebellion members filled an intersection near Vancouver International Airport.

During the pre-trial hearing on June 10 at Richmond Provincial Court, a lawyer for a third protester, Kathleen Elisabeth Higgins, said she would present novel arguments at trial that her client is not guilty on constitutional grounds. 

A trial date is to be determined, but the court heard that the Crown case is expected to last five days. As many as 14 police officers could be called to testify and there are four hours of video evidence. 

Lawyers for two other protesters, Shy-Anne Gunville and Patti Lula Hirschberg, also appeared, but their clients have not decided their next steps. 

Earlier this year, Haq, a student from Pakistan, and Brazier, a website and clothing designer from England, formed the Extinction Rebellion splinter group Save Old Growth that demands the NDP government ban all old-growth logging. 

Federal records show Haq and Brazier federally incorporated a not-for-profit company called Eco-Mobilization Canada on Jan. 27 with fellow protesters Ian Shigeaki Weber, Hannah Campbell and Olivia Mary Howe. They finance their activities by crowdfunding and grants from the U.S.-based Climate Emergency Fund (CEF), which has doled-out $1.7 million to 23 groups in 2022. CEF co-founder Trevor Neilson of Beverly Hills, Calif. is the chair and CEO of Wasteful, which converts trash and agricultural waste to fuel. The board includes documentary filmmaker Rory Kennedy, daughter of Robert Kennedy, and Aileen Getty, daughter of oil baron Jean Paul Getty II.

Save Old Growth’s highway and bridge blockade tactics, that are intended to disrupt the economy, have angered commuters throughout the Lower Mainland and Southern Vancouver Island and led to numerous arrests and mischief charges. The group has also been involved in hunger strikes, threatened a citizen’s arrest of NDP Forests Minister Katrine Conroy, dumped manure at Premier John Horgan’s Langford riding office and sent a topless protester to attach herself to a goalpost at B.C. Place Stadium during Canada’s men’s soccer match with Curaçao. 

The group predicts environmental breakdown will occur in March 2025.

A member of an associated campaign in Ontario, Stop the Project, recently threw buckets of paint on the exterior of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s office in Ottawa. 

On Feb. 15 in B.C. Supreme Court, Justice Shelley Fitzpatrick sentenced Haq to 14 days in jail for contempt after his September 2021 arrest for blocking tree-clearing for the construction of the Trans Mountain Pipeline. 

Fitzpatrick acknowledged Haq said members of Extinction Rebellion are non-violent, but she said aspects relating to Haq were “concerning,” including comments he made to the Vancouver Sun about the potential for violence stemming from the pipeline. 

B.C. Supreme Court Justice Shelley Fitzpatrick

“He refers to ‘forcing government change’. He refers to the government actions as being ‘treason’. These are very troubling comments, in my view,” Fitzpatrick said. 

Haq was released after nine days from the North Fraser Pretrial Centre and joked in an Instagram video outside the facility about spending his time watching Seinfeld reruns in jail.

Meanwhile, a campaign backed by the pro-development Resource Works Society is urging British Columbians affected by Save Old Growth roadblocks to gather evidence and join a proposed class-action lawsuit. 

Tamara Meggitt of Clear the Road cited the successful court action by Ottawa residents against the so-called freedom convoy trucker blockades earlier this year. 

“Freedom of expression is protected by Section 2 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, but expressing a point of view about an issue does not confer the right to commit criminal acts,” Meggitt said in a news release. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

 

1 Comment

Bob Mackin Lawyers for two organizers of a

Business, News, Opinion

For the week of June 12, 2022:

The long-awaited report from the B.C. Coroners Service, released June 7, said 619 people died due to excessive heat from June 25 to July 1, 2021. 

The heat dome was the worst natural disaster in Canadian history. But it didn’t have to be.

Meteorologist David Jones

A legacy of the deadly July 2009 heat wave was a new, two-step system to warn British Columbians developed in 2012 by David Jones. He was the coastal warning preparedness meteorologist at Environment Canada’s Pacific storm prediction centre until he retired in 2017. 

“Meteorologists actually have an opportunity to prevent death,” Jones told theBreaker.news Podcast host Bob Mackin. 

Late afternoon June 23, 2021 came and the weather office forecast a dangerous, long-lasting heat wave. Provincial health and public safety officials did nothing to warn the public or muster resources on June 24. 

“It would’ve been the perfect time to launch that deadly heat alert,” Jones said. 

It was too little, too late, when the Vancouver Coastal and Fraser Health authorities issued their extreme heat warning before supper hour on June 25. 

Hear more from Jones on the report by the Coroner and the B.C. government’s response. 

Also, a commentary on how the NDP government buried a report recommending changes to the freedom of information laws, and headlines from the Pacific Rim and Pacific Northwest. 

CLICK BELOW to listen or go to TuneIn or Apple Podcasts.

Now on Google Podcasts!

Have you missed an edition of theBreaker.news Podcast? Go to the archive.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast: Heat dome warning was too little, too late
Loading
/
0 Comments

For the week of June 12, 2022: The

Business, News

Bob Mackin

Site C had the highest rate of management and professional resignations in BC Hydro during the last fiscal year, according to a management briefing note.

Site C dam under construction (BC Hydro)

A Feb. 15 briefing note that studying pay increase guidelines, obtained via freedom of information, said there had been 101 resignations out of 2,896 active employees, a 3.5% average across nine business groups that reported resignations. The reasons for leaving the Crown utility corporation were not disclosed in the briefing note. 

At Site C, the $16 billion megaproject, there had been 23 resignations out of 256 active management and professional employees, a 9% rate. That includes 10 leaving the 101-strong engineering group, seven quitting from the 61-person project controls, risks and services, and three exiting the 19-employee division that includes regulatory and communications workers — a rate of 15.8%. 

BC Hydro’s operations department had the lowest resignation rate, at 0.6% (three workers out of 465), followed by safety and compliance’s 2.5% (3/122) and customer and corporate affairs’ 2.9% (8/77). 

The briefing note said the executive team’s Jan. 25 meeting included discussion on how to use the management and professional salary increase budget that was awaiting approval at the people and culture committee the following week. 

There were four options, three of which censored. The briefing note recommended higher common guidelines for all employees and hiking pay for specific jobs that are further behind market rates and/or experiencing more attraction and retention challenges.

BC Hydro headquarters (BC Hydro)

“This option provides higher salary increase guidelines that would be equally applied to all jobs and employees,” the briefing note said. “Salary increase guidelines are shared with employees and managers. A two-tiered salary increase model would generate a negative reaction from employees in the “have not” group.”

The data charts were censored, though one included a preamble that said BC Hydro sought labour market advice from Willis Towers Watson and Morneau Shepell (now LifeWorks).

The briefing note said the pay increases were forecast to reduce the gap between male and female salaries from 2.2% to 1.9%. 

According to the December 2021 annual gender pay report, which only looked at management and professional salaries, there was no difference for unionized workers represented by MoveUp and International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers due to fixed wage rates in collective agreements. 

“As there were no salary increases in 2021, we were not able to reduce this gap further compared to the previous year,” the briefing note said.

The briefing note said BC Hydro is committed to equal pay for equal work and its pay structures are set-up as gender neutral. In its annual monitoring report, females in BC Hydro management and professional jobs averaged one year younger than male counterparts and had six months less service.  

“This accounts for part of the pay difference. However, a primary factor continues to be the underrepresentation of females in higher paying jobs, such as in engineering and operations,” the document said. “Until such time that the gender representation is more balanced in these groups or jobs are paid similar salaries, a salary gap will persist when comparing overall average salaries.”

According to Glassdoor.ca, which ranks corporate and government salaries, BC Hydro ranges from $96,678 to $183,559. “When factoring in bonuses and additional compensation, a manager at BC Hydro can expect to make an average total pay of $130,624 per year.”

BC Hydro’s 2021 statement of financial information, said it paid out $781.6 million in remuneration. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

0 Comments

Bob Mackin Site C had the highest rate

Business, News

Bob Mackin

Not only did B.C. opposition leader Kevin Falcon miss the deadline to file his leadership campaign financing report, but he blew way past the BC Liberal Party’s $600,000 spending limit. 

Falcon spent $1.078 million to become leader on Feb. 5, according to the Elections BC returns released June 8.

Kevin Falcon and BC Liberal leadership candidates except Val Litwin (BC Liberals/Facebook)

Elections BC fined Falcon and fellow contestants Val Litwin and Renee Merrifield $500 each for missing the May 6 deadline and gave them until June 6 to comply. Stan Sipos was also granted an extension, but not fined, due to unspecified extenuating circumstances. 

Falcon’s biggest line item was $519,396.40 for professional services, followed by $282,002.27 for staff expenses, GST, bad debt and net Liberal Party expenditures, and $106,866.38 for social functions. The report does not name suppliers. 

The $1,078,220.32 figure for total contestant expenses appears above a crossed-out total of $3,234.66.96. Falcon did not respond for comment. 

Advertising, normally one of the biggest expenses for a political campaign, came in at $28,226.71, slightly more than the $26,288.75 Falcon reported for personal expenses. 

Falcon’s team claims it spent only $12,000 on research and data, including polling.

As of Feb. 15, Falcon’s leadership campaign owed $100,000 in loans to RBC at a 2.95% interest rate.  

The campaign took in $923,576.18, including $816,796.18 in direct donations and the rest in transfers from the central party. 

Prominent donors included Falcon’s boss at Anthem Properties Eric Carlson ($1,200), developer Rick Ilich ($1,268.07), White Spot and Shato Holdings owner Peter Toigo ($1,268.07), real estate agent Karim Virani ($1,000), political strategist and lobbyist Patrick Kinsella ($1,250) and former B.C. government deputy ministers John Dyble ($1,268.07) and Dan Doyle ($1,268).

Falcon returned $13,669.99 in illegal donations. The largest was $3,804 from Golden Top Financial Services, which bills itself as a non-bank financial institution that focuses on providing home mortgage services for overseas Chinese.

Only individuals are allowed to donate to political campaigns in B.C. 

There were also 43 prohibited individual donations $31.83 each over the individual limit and 10 $31.93 over the limit. All of which were dated at the start of May, but returned at the end of the month. Though the Elections BC donation limit for 2022 is $1,309.09, the BC Liberal leadership race was called in 2021 when the maximum was $1,268.07. 

In total, the seven candidates raised $2.28 million. 

Gavin Dew, Michael Lee and runner-up Ellis Ross filed on time, but the reports released May 11 showed that Lee exceeded the party-imposed $600,000 spending limit by $42,000. 

On Feb. 5, Falcon won the phone and online contest on the fifth ballot with 52.19% of weighted votes (4,541.35 points) to Ross’s 33.65% (2,928.33). Lee was third with 14.14% (1,230.31).

The race was held under a cloud of controversy as Falcon opponents complained about fraudulent memberships. With hours to go in voting on Feb. 5, a BC Supreme judge rejected a petition from BC Liberal member Vikram Bajwa that aimed to delay the release of results by 15 days in order to investigate the allegations.

Kevin Falcon enters the Wall Centre ballroom on Feb. 5 (BC Liberals/Facebook)

In early January, managers for five of the candidates wrote party brass seeking an audit of party membership sales. An internal party audit found more than 32,000 new memberships were sold B.C.-wide, with much of the growth concentrated in Surrey and Abbotsford riding associations.

Lee’s campaign manager, Diamond Isinger, complained in a Jan. 31 email to the party that contractor Votem did not have basic safeguards to limit the use of multiple IP addresses and virtual private networks, nor was the party allowing real-time scrutineers.

When Lee confronted Falcon at the Jan. 18 candidates’ debate, Falcon dismissed the allegations and accused Lee of “creating a cloud of distrust.”

North Vancouver-resident Falcon handily won an April 30 by-election in Vancouver-Quilchena to fill the seat vacated by ex-leader Andrew Wilkinson. Falcon was sworn-in on May 16, three days after Premier John Horgan announced the controversial $1 billion Royal B.C. Museum replacement. 

The runner-up in the 2011 leadership race to Christy Clark quit politics in 2012 after 11 years in multiple cabinet portfolios and became executive vice-president at developer Anthem Properties.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

0 Comments

Bob Mackin Not only did B.C. opposition leader

Business, News

Bob Mackin

It is now a three-way race for Mayor of Surrey. 

Jinny Sims, the NDP MLA in Surrey-Panorama, launched her campaign to defeat Mayor Doug McCallum and his Safe Surrey Coalition on June 8 under the banner of Surrey Forward. She joins Coun. Brenda Locke, who declared her candidacy with the new Surrey Connect party in July 2021.

Stephen Carter (Twitter)

“Surrey city hall is broken,” Sims said in a prepared statement. “There are two factions at city hall fighting with each other instead of fighting for the people of Surrey.”

With just over four months until election day, Sims is playing catch-up, so she imported the strategist behind the last two mayors of Calgary to manage her campaign. 

Stephen Carter helped Naheed Nenshi get elected in 2010 and his successor Jyoti Gondek last fall. Carter was Gondek’s chief of staff until February when he was fired mysteriously with a $104,000 severance. 

“I was dismissed without cause,” Carter said. “I think I’ve spoken to the Calgary media quite extensively.”

Carter also managed Alison Redford’s 2011 Alberta Progressive Conservative leadership campaign and 2012 provincial election win. He became her chief of staff, but left that job after six months with a $130,000 severance. 

Asked if he would follow Sims into a Surrey city hall job if she wins on Oct. 15, Carter said his agreement with Sims is for the campaign only. “That’s what the deals that I always sign are,” he said.

The Punjab-born, England-raised Sims is a former high school teacher who parlayed her profile as president of the B.C. Teachers Federation into a successful run for the NDP in the federal Newton-North Delta riding in 2011. She lost in 2015 to Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal, but went provincial and won Surrey-Panorama for the B.C. NDP in 2017. 

Jinny Sims (Surrey Forward)

Sims resigned as Minister of Citizens’ Services in October 2019 over allegations she hid email and wrote visa support letters for campaign supporters. Special prosecutor Richard Peck did not recommend charges against Sims, who had been in charge of the government’s procurement and freedom of information departments. Peck, coincidentally, is now the defence lawyer in McCallum’s public mischief case, which is scheduled for trial two weeks after election day. 

Sims was re-elected in 2020, but not reappointed to cabinet.

“The relationship between Sims and [Premier John Horgan] has been super strong throughout all of this,” Carter said. “Both of them have tremendous respect for one another. I don’t think that her not being in cabinet was any reflection of those allegations.” 

Carter also worked on Mike Hurley’s 2018 defeat of longtime Burnaby Mayor Derek Corrigan. Earlier that year, he managed Mike de Jong’s second unsuccessful campaign for the BC Liberal leadership. 

He said Surrey voters are looking for a more predictable and fair mayor than McCallum, and Sims will also stress affordability.  

As for the timing of Sims’s campaign launch, Carter said more than 50% of a candidate’s funds are generally raised and spent in the last four-to-six weeks of a campaign, “right when people are expecting to see a lot.”

“Jinny Sims also has name recognition, whereas Jyoti Gondek, her name recognition was less than 10%,” Carter said. “When we started, we had a totally different task.”

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

0 Comments

Bob Mackin It is now a three-way race

Business, News, Sports

Bob Mackin

A Crown prosecutor asked a Provincial Court judge in North Vancouver on June 8 to send a former Canadian national women’s team and Vancouver Whitecaps’ coach to jail for two years less a day.

Bob Birarda in 2005 (CSA)

Robert Steven (Bob) Birarda, 55, pleaded guilty in February to three counts of sexual assault and one count of touching a young person for sexual purpose. 

At the beginning of the sentencing hearing, prosecutor Linda Ostry also asked Judge Deanna Gaffar to put Birarda on probation for three years, entered for life in the sexual offender registry, provide a DNA sample and be banned for 10 years from owning firearms. 

Ostry described how Birarda used his power as a coach and mentor to groom each of his four victims and manipulated and exploited their vulnerability for his own satisfaction. She said he left each of them emotionally scarred, detached from their families and friends, and the game they loved to play. 

“These were young women who did have aspirations in that world, and we see from the victim impact statement, that it became difficult and ultimately impossible for them to continue on in that world,” Ostry told the court. 

Birarda was formally charged in December 2020 with nine offences in Burnaby, North Vancouver and West Vancouver stemming from historical sexual offences between 1988 and 1990, 1995 and 2006 to 2008. A tenth charge was added, but six were dropped under a plea bargain. The court dates were repeatedly postponed throughout 2021 due to the pandemic, scheduling conflicts and negotiations between lawyers.

Names of the victims are covered by a publication ban, but Ostry recounted each of the crimes Birarda committed in the statement of facts agreed with Birarda’s lawyer, William Smart. 

Ostry described the personal circumstances of each of the four victims and how Birarda groomed them. One of the victims told police that “she feared she could lose opportunities to continue in soccer if she challenged him.”

Another victim described how, instead of Birarda taking her to a doctor after a minor car crash in January 1995, he took her back to his basement suite and gave her an unwanted massage. 

CSA and Whitecaps

“She stated to police that she felt trapped, like she ‘had no option to leave’,” Ostry said.

Another said after a game in 1990 in Burnaby, she was alone with Birarda in the middle of the pitch where he suddenly took her in his arms, kissed her passionately and intimately with his tongue. She pulled away, but Birarda said he wanted to have sex with her right there, in the centre of the field. She was scared and told him he should do that with his wife. The victim broke away from Birarda and waited in her car, “shaking, trying to calm down.”

Shen went to the team’s pool party feeling exposed and vulnerable, wanting to tell somebody, but didn’t know how to begin. 

Ostry said Birarda referred to another victim player’s upcoming 18th birthday as “e-day” or ecstasy day and openly fantasized about taking her to Paris for sex. The court heard that she began wearing baggy clothes to practice and asked Birarda if their relationship could return to that of “player-coach.”

That player and her parents complained in 2008 to West Vancouver Police Department and provided copies of email, in which Birarda took an aggressive, dominating tone. No charges were recommended, but in October of 2008, both the Whitecaps and Canadian Soccer Association announced that they mutually split with Birarda “in the best interest of both parties.” Neither the Whitecaps nor CSA mentioned any alleged misconduct in that 2008 media announcement, which happened after they hired a lawyer to investigate. 

Birarda was not supposed to return to coaching girls’ youth soccer. But, in February 2019, former Whitecap and national team player Ciara McCormack revealed that he was coaching Coastal FC in South Surrey. In a viral blog post, McCormack described how Whitecaps president Bob Lenarduzzi breached her confidence in 2007 when she complained to him about Birarda’s bullying and harassment. 

A dozen players from the 2008 Whitecaps and national team issued a public statement, alleging “incidents of abuse, manipulation, or inappropriate behaviour” by Birarda in 2007 and 2008. It sparked the Vancouver Police to investigate. North Vancouver RCMP eventually assumed the file.

North Vancouver Provincial Court (B.C. Courthouse Libraries)

Early in the 2019 Major League Soccer season, Whitecaps supporters grew unhappy with the team’s response to the scandal and organized match boycotts and first half walkouts at Major League Soccer games in B.C. Place. Owners Greg Kerfoot and Jeff Mallett eventually apologized to the players and admitted that Birarda’s contract was cancelled in 2008 due to sexually inappropriate text messages with a player, contrary to policies of both the club and national association. 

They ordered an internal review by a Toronto law firm. In August 2019, Lenarduzzi was demoted from president to club liaison.

A pre-sentencing expert report on Birarda said he acknowledged the harm he did to his victims and that he had experienced anxiety, depression and thoughts of suicide. He was briefly hospitalized and sought counselling and medication, but has not been treated for his sexual offences.

Smart did not have a chance to address the judge until the end of the day, so the hearing will continue on a date to be determined.  

He said the author of a psychological report on Birarda misunderstood some facts and he would present letters of support from young women that Birarda coached since 2008. 

“My submission that he doesn’t pose a risk in the future, and he has, over the last 14 years effectively rehabilitated himself,” Smart said. 

Birarda coached the Whitecaps women’s team to the 2006 W-League championship, missed the 2007 playoffs and advanced to the conference finals in 2008. He headed the under-20 national women’s team and assisted on Canada’s team that lost on penalty kicks to the U.S. in the quarter-finals of the Beijing 2008 Summer Olympics.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

0 Comments

Bob Mackin A Crown prosecutor asked a Provincial

Business, News, Sports

Bob Mackin

Three B.C. Place Stadium workers excluded from workplace inclusivity training sessions have accused the public-owned stadium’s management of discrimination. 

Heavy duty mechanic Salim Kesani, who has worked at the stadium since 2004, complained to the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal (HRT) in 2020 after being told he was left out for negative comments about management. Technician Bill Bains and ex-mechanic Shane Hussein also filed complaints over the exclusion.

B.C. Place’s retractable roof (Mackin)

“This is a very toxic environment. It’s so toxic, it’s almost nuclear,” Kesani said.

The jobs of all three were reclassified when management merged two departments, a bureaucratic move that the three men say deprived them of pay raises between $2 and $5 per hour.

No hearing date has been set. Bains, Hussein and Kesani say the B.C. Pavilion Corp. (PavCo)-retained lawyer from the labour relations firm Harris and Co. has slowed down their cases. 

Kesani complained to Premier John Horgan and Labour Minister Harry Bains on May 2, but said he received no response. The ministry communications office said Bains had no comment on the letter, because “human rights issues are handled by the independent Human Rights Tribunal.”

Kesani said working conditions have deteriorated since 2010 when the stadium hosted Winter Olympics ceremonies and temporarily closed for a major renovation and roof replacement.

“If it’s not racism, it must be some other kind of discrimination,” Kesani said. “Maybe they don’t like your face, or maybe they don’t like the way you look. But there is a degree of discrimination, in one way or the other.”

In a January 2022 affidavit about Kesani, B.C. Place human resources and labour relations director Wayne Smith said training held in October and November 2019 for approximately 450 employees covered respect, bullying, harassment, diversity, inclusion and unconscious bias. According to Smith, colour or race had nothing to do with deeming four workers unwelcome.

“The decision not to invite the complainant and the other three employees was due to their demonstrated negativity towards B.C. Place management and their behaviour in previous group meetings,” said Smith’s affidavit.

The affidavit said Smith provided Kesani a copy of the materials used in the training session at a meeting in November 2019. It also made a reference to Kesani apologizing at that meeting to Nick Montpetit, the senior facility operations manager, for calling him a liar at a focus group. But no other incidents were mentioned. In Kesani’s response, he maintains that employees were encouraged to speak freely at the specific meeting about an employee engagement survey. 

Inside B.C. Place Stadium (Mackin)

Smith’s affidavit also claimed two of the four excluded workers are Caucasian. 

However, Bains, Hussein and Kesani are South Asian. 

Bains, a B.C. Place worker since 1984, said in his complaint that the exclusion from inclusivity training made him feel unworthy of learning, development, support and safety. He also had complained about someone using his name in workplace graffiti in order to insult him.

On the pay issue, electricians, plumbers and HVAC employees were reclassified from trades to technicians in late November 2019 when maintenance and engineering and facility operations divisions were merged. The stadium and B.C. General Employees’ Union (BCGEU) agreed on five new classifications and wage rates.

“The objective was to build one skilled team with facility operations to work on the preventative maintenance program, including complex and proprietary systems,” said the Smith affidavit. “This team is comprised of the [full-time] conversion specialists and tradespeople. Conversion specialists need to be trained on preventative maintenance, and the tradespeople are responsible for that training.”

Conversion specialists work to change the stadium setup between soccer, football, concert and trade show modes. 

BCGEU spokesperson Erin Sikora said the union would not comment without worker consent. After Selani consented, Sikora said the union could not comment because it was not representing him at the HRT. PavCo CEO Ken Cretney did not respond for comment.

Bains did not seek union help with his human rights complaint, because the BCGEU was involved in the reclassification deal with management. He disputes Smith’s allegations of insubordination and disrespect and has filed multiple grievances over his treatment. 

“They were trying to force me out,” Bains said. 

Hussein worked 15 years at B.C. Place and said he was fired after missing work to care for his ill wife and daughter in January and to work at his other job on SkyTrain. His dispute has gone to arbitration. 

BCGEU workers at the stadium rejected a new contract offer last fall, but reached a new deal in February after mediation. It includes pay increases retroactive to 2020.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

0 Comments

Bob Mackin Three B.C. Place Stadium workers excluded

m
About Us

theBreaker.news and theBreaker.news Podcast: your source for news, opinion and analysis about British Columbia issues, institutions and influencers.

Contact
theBreaker is located in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada and published by Bob Mackin.
Email: bob@thebreaker.news
Send tips via secure Protonmail theBreakernews@protonmail.com
Support theBreaker.news
For as low as $2 a month, you can help support theBreaker.news on Patreon
Support theBreaker.news on Patreon
Find out how by clicking here!