Recent Posts
Connect with:
Saturday / April 20.
  • No products in the cart.
HomeStandard Blog Whole Post (Page 137)

Bob Mackin

A major North Vancouver-based chain of auto body repair garages hopes it will be business as usual this weekend after suffering a cyberattack two weeks ago.

(Craftsman Collision)

Craftsman Collision chief operating officer Rick Hatswell told theBreaker.news that the company had to shut down computer systems and deal manually with ICBC claims. Someone inadvertently clicked on a malicious email that triggered ransomware which, according to Norton security, locks and encrypts a victim’s computer or device data, then demands ransom to restore access.

Hatswell said the hackers grabbed the company’s web domain and sent emails that appeared to be from Craftsman.

“We just started getting hit with all the phishing emails all at once so we recognized it pretty quick. When we shut it down we had to rebuild from back up which has taken us quite a bit of time,” Hatswell said in an interview. “As of now we’re back up to business, it should be every shop by tomorrow. The IT department has been burning the candle at both ends getting everything rebuilt, getting all the servers up and running so the shops can reconnect with head office.”

ICBC had to send staff to examine vehicles needing repair at Craftsman, an accredited repair facility normally connected to the Express Repair program for damage estimates and approvals.

Craftsman Collision locations billed ICBC $80.7 million for the year ended March 31, 2019, according to the Crown corporation’s statement of financial information.

ICBC spokesperson Joanna Linsangan said in a prepared statement that the auto insurer took immediate steps to safeguard its customer information.

“We’ve conducted an assessment of our own systems, and can confirm that our customer data has not been compromised. We will continue to work with Craftsman Collision to determine if there remains to be a risk to our customer’s information,” Linsangan said.

Craftsman Collision president Rick Hatswell (Craftsman Collision/Facebook)

Craftsman hired a third-party specialist to get the company back online and conduct a full forensic investigation to find out how much damage the hackers did. Hatswell believes very little was affected because the company acted quickly.

“We don’t keep much on file other than name, phone number and address. There is no banking info, it’s all done through ICBC’s side for payments, so at least there is no information of that type or passwords or anything like that,” he said. “We don’t believe anything was taken at all.”

Hatswell said he tried to report the incident to the RCMP, but “they basically turned me down.” He was referred to the Ontario-based Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre toll-free hotline. Hatswell said the company intends to notify customers.

“I don’t know who to actually call to be honest, I know our third-party would know, but when I reached out locally nobody seemed to care, there was no money lost.”

Information and Privacy Commissioner Michael McEvoy said his office had not been notified. The Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner encourages both public bodies and private sector organizations to voluntarily report privacy breaches via a form on the OIPC website. There is no mandatory reporting law, despite a 2017 NDP campaign promise.

During the last provincial election, the NDP told the B.C. Information and Privacy Association that, if it came to power, the party “will consider best practices both across Canada and internationally for breach notifications in both the public and private sectors to determine a made-in-B.C. policy.”

“We agree that mandatory breach notification would benefit the public by enhancing accountability and transparency, and helping to mitigate the serious fallouts of privacy breaches and as government we will take action,” said an April 2017 NDP letter in response to a questionnaire.

Roger Gale, a BCIT industrial network cybersecurity instructor, told CTV that privacy breach reporting is necessary.

“Many organizations, companies will not want to report data breaches, it hits their public perception, it hits their bottom line, but I think there has to be a political will to bring in legislation like that,” Gale told reporter Alissa Thibault. “When it comes to data security, I think that the governments are moving at a snail’s pace, compared to the hackers out there.”

B.C. Information and Privacy Commissioner Michael McEvoy (Mackin)

On Dec. 12, New Zealand-based Emsisoft Malware Lab published its “The State of Ransomware in the U.S.: Report and Statistics” and warned that the threat of ransomware had reached a crisis level.

In 2019, the U.S. was hit by an unprecedented and unrelenting barrage of ransomware attacks that impacted at least 948 government agencies, educational establishments and healthcare providers at a potential cost in excess of $7.5 billion,” the report said.

According to Emsisoft, existing security weaknesses and the development of increasingly sophisticated attack mechanisms designed to exploit those weaknesses have created a “near-perfect storm.” It recommended improved security standards and oversight, more guidance and better public-private sector cooperation.

On Dec. 13, New Orleans City Hall activated the civic emergency operations centre after a cyberattack.

As for Hatswell, he does expect a hit to Craftsman Collision’s bottom line during what is generally the slowest month of the year.

“I’m hoping it’s obviously not in the millions, but having 37 stores in B.C., I’m sure it’s in the hundreds of thousands of lost revenue. When the RCMP says ‘well you haven’t paid out anything,’ well, there’s a lot of other costs on rebuilding software, hiring companies and the lost revenue.”

Request for comment from the office of Attorney General David Eby, the minister in charge of ICBC, was not fulfilled by deadline.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin A major North Vancouver-based chain of

Bob Mackin

Vancouver Mayor Kennedy Stewart should repay taxpayers for his campaign-style video that cost nearly $8,000, says an independent watchdog.

Documents obtained under freedom of information by theBreaker.news show that Stewart’s “One Year In” video cost $7,875. Evan Crowe, who was a video producer and digital coordinator on the B.C. NDP’s 2017 campaign, sent an invoice Nov. 7 for production and post-production of the Nov. 5-published Facebook video.

Scenes from Mayor Kennedy Stewart’s first anniversary ad (City of Vancouver)

The slick, 54-second ad emphasizes Stewart’s three goals of building the right supply of housing, tackling the opioid overdose crisis and extending SkyTrain to the University of B.C. Nov. 5 was the anniversary of labour-backed independent Stewart’s swearing-in after edging the NPA’s Ken Sim by 957 votes in the civic election.

Dermod Travis of IntegrityBC called it a “slap in the face to every ratepayer in Vancouver.”

“His office budget, city funds are not for his personal benefit, they are not to assist him in seeking re-election, they are there to provide services to citizens, not services to campaign organizers, campaign advisors and campaign strategists,” Travis said. “He has an obligation to take a look at that video, to take a look at how he has used that video and to return the money to the taxpayers of Vancouver.”

The video shows Stewart with Premier John Horgan and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and mainstreeting with his wife, political science professor Jeanette Ashe. It ends with City of Vancouver branding and was embedded in a Nov. 5 email to Stewart campaign supporters with a link to his fundraising website.

Spokesman Alvin Singh did not fulfil theBreaker.news request to interview Stewart. In an interview, Singh called the expenditure “extraordinarily small.”

Mayor Kennedy Stewart’s wife, Jeanette Ashe, appears on the right in Stewart’s first anniversary video (City of Vancouver)

“It represents fractions upon fractions upon fractions of budget. The city’s operating budget is $1.5 billion,” Singh said.

CTV’s St. John Alexander caught-up with Stewart at the TransLink Mayors’ Council meeting in New Westminster.

“I think people expect me to communicate with them and this is one way that we do it,” Stewart said.

He said it is a way of communicating to other levels of government what he is doing and to cut through the “tidal wave of information,” from Donald Trump to Brexit, consumed by the public.

“I think that communicating with the public is essential,” Stewart said. “There’s a lot of questions in the city and making sure that they know where we’re delivering is very important, so I’ll continue to communicate with the public in this way, because, I think if I didn’t, people would say ‘where is he’?”

Ex-NPA city councillor George Affleck, who runs a digital marketing company, said Stewart is following in the footsteps of his mayoral predecessor, Gregor Robertson. He questioned the timing, because city council is wrestling with a proposed 9.3% increase in property taxes and utility fees.

“We have this massive budget increase, and here we have the mayor of our city spending taxpayer dollars to do a promotional video,” Affleck told CTV. “This kind of approach where governments in power spend taxpayer dollars to promote themselves Is very frustrating for taxpayers, there’s a lot of cynicism about politics and when he talks about togetherness, he’s pushing people away in fact.”

The Mayor’s Office was allotted $1.345 million of the $3.144 million budgeted for mayor and council this year. That includes $80,000 for professional fees and $91,000 for miscellaneous, including $9,000 for public information.

In April 2018, theBreaker.news reported that Robertson gave more than $51,000 in patronage contracts to Mark Vonesch, a Vision Vancouver cameraman who pretended to be a media worker during the 2014 election campaign. 

Travis said there are “loads of cost-effective means” for politicians who feel they must communicate by video to constituents.

“Simply using a webcam, Skype, hand-held video recorder,” he said. “Frankly, some of the best ads that come out of the U.S. proven to be some of the least costly because they are done in a very homegrown style by the candidate or the campaign.”

On Nov. 29, Stewart announced he was running for re-election in 2022 in a fundraising email.

“I think Vancouver ratepayers would rather have a mayor who cares about the here and now than 2022,” Travis said.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin Vancouver Mayor Kennedy Stewart should

Bob Mackin

A Courtenay resident opposed to the NDP government’s restrictions on residential use of farmland said it was no surprise her petition was rejected in late October.

Delta South BC Liberal MLA Ian Paton presenting a petition before it was quietly rejected (Hansard TV)

Meghan McPherson organized an Oct. 28 rally against Bills 52 and 15 outside the Legislature. Her aim is to reverse the ban on secondary, non-farm-use family housing.

Inside the Legislature, Delta South MLA and agriculture critic Ian Paton, a farmer himself, tabled McPherson’s 26,000-signatory Change.org petition as a “30-pound stack” of paper in a box after a raucous question period interrupted by farmers and ranchers in the public gallery.

The petition was later returned to Paton by the clerk’s office because “all signatures must be original and written directly on the face of the petition, and not pasted or transferred to it.” Electronic petitions are not allowed.

McPherson said she was called by an aide to Agriculture Minister Lana Popham the week before the rally and told about the rule. She said Paton also knew the petition was unacceptable. (Paton did not reply to theBreaker.news.) McPherson said she is confident at least half the digital signatories are genuine B.C. residents. 

“Whether it was in a formal format or not it would be up to the ministry and the current government to decide what they are going to do with it,” McPherson said in an interview. “It shows a lot of defiance to reject a 26,000-signature petition on a technicality.”

Oct. 28 rally by farmers and ranchers outside the Legislature (Facebook)

McPherson said she used Change.org for convenience. She did not have the time or resources to go door-to-door on her own. 

It was at least the second BC Liberal-tabled petition to be rejected in the last two years. A 17,000-name “Scrap the Speculation Tax” petition via Change.org in April 2018 was returned to Kelowna West MLA Ben Stewart. The originator of the petition refused to reveal his or her name to theBreaker.news. That petition ran concurrently with Hill and Knowlton’s anti-tax social media campaign for the Urban Development Institute.

More than a century ago, Austrian politician and historian Joseph Redlich called the petition “the oldest of all parliamentary forms, the fertile seed of all the proceedings of the House of Commons.” 

Twice, while in opposition, the NDP failed to modernize petitions via private member’s bills: In 2014 with Jane Shin’s Electronic Petitions Act and in 2017 with Gary Holman’s Modernizing Public Participation in Democracy Act. 

A model for electronic petitions exists at the House of Commons.

While he was Burnaby South NDP MP, Kennedy Stewart successfully proposed a system of MP-endorsed citizen petitions that are published up to 120 days on the House of Commons website. Supporters are required to provide full names, province, territory and country of residence, postal code (if within Canada), telephone number and email address for verification by House of Commons staff.

Those petitions that receive 500 or more online signatories from residents or citizens of Canada are tabled in the House of Commons to wait for an official response from the government. 

The path of an e-petition (Petitions.OurCommons.ca)

Stewart is now mayor of Vancouver, but has not fulfilled a 2018 campaign promise for a city hall electronic petition system.

McPherson said she and her family moved out of a townhouse and bought a one-hectare parcel on a hillside with a plan to start a hobby farm.

“It was a dream property for us, a place we could stay forever with his parents and my mom, a place for a hobby farm, chickens and goats and build a barn,” she said. “I just wanted to have a nice little rural property with a teeny farm, maybe sell some eggs, maybe feed my neighbourhood.”

Now she is looking at an estimated $800,000 in startup fees to turn it into a farm that conforms with the laws. Undaunted, McPherson plans to start a paper-based petition in the new year, with help from others elsewhere in B.C. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin A Courtenay resident opposed to the

Bob Mackin

An indigenous leader claims he was dumped as chair of the First Nations Health Authority after accusing the chief executive officer of conflict of interest.

Grand Chief Doug Kelly (FNHA)

Grand Chief Doug Kelly, president of the Sto:lo Tribal Council, filed a B.C. Supreme Court lawsuit against the authority on Dec. 6, claiming he is owed more than $380,000 for breach of contract.

The 59-year-old alleged he had 25 months left as the $183,000-a-year chair of the West Vancouver-based authority. The authority is responsible for programs that were formerly delivered to 200 B.C. First Nations communities by Health Canada. The federal government committed $4.7 billion from 2013 to 2022 and the B.C. government agreed to chip-in $83.5 million. 

Kelly’s lawsuit said CEO Joe Gallagher recommended in 2017 that the board create a new position of vice-president of policy, planning and quality to report directly to him. He also recommended that his ex-wife, Harmony Johnson, fill the role on an acting basis. Kelly claimed that Gallagher did not follow policy because he failed to formally disclose his interest in Johnson’s appointment.

In meetings and emails last April, Kelly raised concerns with Gallagher and others in the authority about Johnson’s hiring. In May, Kelly made a presentation to the board on good governance issues, including implications of a 2016 report by the Auditor General of Canada and Gallagher’s apparent conflict of interest.

Joe Gallagher (BC Pharmacy)

“The report pointed to gaps and inadequacies in the authority’s conflict of interest policy, and found that the authority did not fully comply with its policies on investigating misconduct and on staffing positions on the basis of merit,” Kelly’s lawsuit said.

The council met to discuss the issue in mid-June and struck a working group of five members, including Kelly and deputy chair Allan Louis. Later that month, the board directed Gallagher to fire Johnson. But, according to Kelly’s statement of claim, Gallagher refused to comply.

On June 28, the board advised the authority members by email that it acted on legal advice to rescind the resolution directing Gallagher to fire Johnson. The council met July 11 and, without notice, voted to remove Kelly and Louis as chair and deputy chair.

The statement of claim said Kelly’s $15,250-a-month contract was part written, part oral and part by conduct. His most-recent three-year term as chair began in October 2018. A fourth year was contingent upon his reappointment to the Sto:lo Tribal Council, which he achieved in March.

“Grand Chief Kelly reasonably expected his appointment as chair, and thus his contract with the authority, to last the entire term, and relied on that expectation to plan his affairs,” said the lawsuit.

Gallagher was dismissed as CEO on Oct. 9, but Johnson remains in her acting vice-president role. Chief operations officer Richard Jock took over as acting CEO.

None of the allegations has been tested in court. The authority has yet to file a defence statement.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin An indigenous leader claims he was

A year ago this week, Huawei chief financial officer Meng Wanzhou was freed on $10 million bail so that she could live at one of her two luxurious Vancouver homes while challenging the United States’ application to extradite her to face fraud charges.

Louis Huang protested outside Meng Wanzhou’s March 6 court date (Mackin)

Across the Pacific, during the same week in 2018, Canadians Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor were arrested by Chinese police in apparent retaliation. 

On Dec. 10, world human rights day, they will be on the minds of Peter Dahlin and millions of others. Dahlin is a human rights activist with the Safeguard Defenders non-government organization. Dahlin spent more than three weeks in a Chinese jail in 2016

“We still don’t really know how Kovrig and Spavor have been treated, all we know is that they’ve obviously been placed under formal arrest now since about six months and we’ve seen very little movement from the Chinese side,” Dahlin told theBreaker.news Podcast host Bob Mackin. “Their cases are no closer to being resolved and that of course points very clearly to this being very much a political process and I don’t see any changes to their legal status for the foreseeable future.”

As 2019 draws to a close with Hong Kong’s pro-democracy struggle and the Xinjiang jailing of a million Uighur Muslims in the news, the two-year countdown to the Beijing Winter Olympics beckons in 2020.

Swedish human rights activist Peter Dahlin in a 2016 forced, false confession (CCTV)

“The IOC, in general, have been very resistant to any changes to their plans going back all the way to the [Berlin] 1936 Olympics and I don’t think we’re going to see a change to that, unfortunately,” Dahlin said. “But, of course, it is going to bring further spotlight to human rights issues, rule of law and how China behaves diplomatically internationally.”

Listen to the full interview with Dahlin.

Plus commentaries and headlines from the Pacific Rim and Pacific Northwest. 

Click below to listen or go to Apple Podcasts and subscribe.

Have you missed an edition of theBreaker.news Podcast? Go to the archive.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast: A year in Lotusland for Meng, a year in Chinese jail for the two Canadian Michaels
Loading
/

A year ago this week, Huawei chief

Bob Mackin

A critic of the Jameson Development Corp. bid to replace the vacant St. Mark’s Anglican Church with a five-storey apartment building is urging Mayor Kennedy Stewart and Coun. Melissa De Genova to recuse themselves from a Dec. 12 public hearing.

Vacant St. Mark’s Church at 1805 Larch (Mackin)

Stuart Rush, who lives near the fenced-off 2nd and Larch site, said Stewart and De Genova risk violating conflict of interest provisions in the Vancouver Charter and Code of Conduct if they participate in any meetings or votes on the spot rezoning. Principals of the development company donated to their 2018 election campaigns and lobbied them after they were sworn-in.

“There is a reasonable conclusion to draw that the mayor and Coun. De Genova have a closed mind on it and that doesn’t sit well with me and that doesn’t sit well with my neighbours,” Rush, a retired lawyer, said in an interview. “We’re saying ‘stand aside mayor, and stand aside Coun. De Genova’ and let the process work where there is not this colouration of influence in respect of your participation and, potentially, your vote.”

People connected to the project donated $4,800 each to Stewart and De Genova’s winning campaigns.

The Elections BC database shows two donations of $1,200 each from Tony Pappajohn and one from Tom Pappajohn to Stewart on Oct. 15, 2018. De Genova received $1,200 each from Thomas Pappajohn, John Pappajohn and Anthony Pappajohn on Oct. 18, 2018.

Graham Thom of Gatland Capital also gave Stewart and De Genova $1,200 each. Gatland’s website said it arranged the $14.25 million land and acquisition financing.

Artist’s rendering of five-storey 1805 Larch proposal (Metric/Jameson)

Rush’s letter to Stewart mentions the Nov. 23, 2018 meeting between the mayor and Tony and Tom Pappajohn. On April 9, Stewart’s chief of staff, Neil Monckton, met with Tony and Tom Pappajohn and lobbyist Raymond Louie, the former city councillor.

In a May 30 speech to the Urban Land Institute, Stewart highlighted the proposed 63-unit rental building, which would include 13 rent-controlled apartments, at 1805 Larch. The Vancouver Sun’s Evan Duggan reported that Stewart sat for lunch at the same table as Louie. 

“You received financial support from the developers for a development that you singled out for public support,” Rush wrote. “You are out there promoting the project. It is clear you will not change your point of view and you have an interest in approving the rezoning and the development proceeding.”

De Genova met Jan. 10 for lunch with Tony Pappajohn at the Hotel Georgia. To her, Rush wrote: “You received financial support from the developers. You met privately with one of the developers two weeks prior to the rezoning application for the site being filed. These facts suggest that you could be influenced or appear to be influenced directly or indirectly by the developers.”

De Genova did not respond for comment. Likewise for Tony and Tom Pappajohn. Alvin Singh, a spokesman for Stewart, said by email that the mayor was not available for an interview.

Mayor Kennedy Stewart (Mackin)

“The issue of donations and hearings has been brought up many times through various administrations and the answer has always been the same: a general donation does not amount to a conflict, real or perceived, around specific development applications,” Singh wrote in a prepared statement. “In terms of his remarks during speeches, the Mayor has used Larch and other projects as examples of the MIRHPP [Moderate Income Rental Housing Pilot Program] policy but hasn’t commented on the merits of the actual development. The speeches also happened prior to referral to public hearing.”

Two decades ago, a Nanaimo city councillor was disqualified from office for voting in favour of a developer who was the biggest backer of his $4,500 re-election campaign.

“The payment to [William Frederick King] was ‘more or less remotely connected with’ the result of the votes he cast in favour of Hazelwood and Northridge,” read the judge’s verdict. “It was a pecuniary interest tied indirectly to the $1,000 contribution.”

Melissa De Genova (Mackin)

However, a B.C. Court of Appeal tribunal overturned the decision in 2001, ruling that the campaign contribution could not “in and of itself” establish direct or indirect pecuniary interest.

All things considered, Rush said, the circumstances around the Larch proposal are “more egregious” than the King case, because it includes elements of lobbying and promotion.

In 2017, the NDP government banned corporate and union donations and set $1,200 as the annual cap for individuals.

In his 2018 campaign, Stewart promised a lobbyist registry. After he was sworn-in, Vancouver city council wrote to the NDP government to ask for the provincial registry to be expanded to cover municipalities. It could have followed the lead of Surrey, which set-up its own registry.

Rush does not oppose development on the site. He said a four-storey structure with only moderate or below market rentals, plus daycare and seniors facilities, would be a better fit for the neighbourhood.

“We’ve had, pulled out of us, a significant centerpoint for community activities, we want to see some of those retained in the functioning structure that evolves,” Rush said. “Where we differentiate from the proposal from the developers is we can see more affordable rentals in there. The developer obviously sees a different financial structure.”

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin A critic of the Jameson Development

Bob Mackin

A collapsed $11.3 million real estate deal in the lucrative Cambie Corridor has sparked a B.C. Supreme Court lawsuit. 

Subject house on Cambie at 37th (BC Assessment/Google)

Bellevilla Development filed Nov. 28 in B.C. Supreme Court against Chi-Jen Lo (aka Jeff Lo), Jeff Lo Personal Real Estate Corp., Lily Gan, Lily Gan Personal Real Estate Corp., Crest Realty dba Re-Max Crest Realty on Nov. 28.

The lawsuit said Bellevilla and Hui Ding jointly retained Gan and Crest in November 2017. Ding allegedly agreed to buy the property at 37th and Cambie personally or through her nominee and alter ego, D&W Investment Ltd., from You Kun Kai and Shu-Chen Cheng on July 22, 2017. Ding was the principal and sole shareholder of the B.C. company.

“Ding would then divest herself of the entirety of her shares in D&W through a sale of those shares to Bellevilla in the subject transaction.”

“Thereafter, Ding assigned the agreement pertaining to the property with the original vendors, to her company D&W in or around late November 2017. D&W would complete the acquisition of the property on or about Feb. 26, 2018.”

Bellevilla would become the sole shareholder in D&W and the sole beneficial owner of the property.

But there was a speedbump. 

“The plaintiff says and the fact is that Lo, Gan and Crest Realty failed to properly advise Bellevilla that the transaction — a share purchase and sale — could not be effected through the use of the aforementioned standard form document.”

Bellevilla claims the original contract was deficient, because there were ambiguities as to the parties, transaction and price.

A contract prepared by the parties’ lawyers on Dec. 6, 2017 contained more details.

The contract was contingent on Bellevilla securing a financing commitment. Bellevilla would provide Ding a first deposit payment of $100,000 within one day of both parties signing and a $400,000 second deposit by Jan. 15, 2018.

But, on June 20, 2018, Bellevilla advised Ding that it was unable to secure satisfactory financing and triggered the financing subject clause in the agreement. Ding filed in B.C. Supreme Court against Bellevilla, seeking liquidated damages for $1.13 million.

The new statement of claim says that deposits and accrued interest remain in the Crest Realty trust account, with an additional $630,000 paid into court as security for the Ding claim. Last year, the 67.5-foot x 140-foot property, containing a one-storey, 1954-built duplex, was assessed at almost $9.06 million. 

None of the allegations has been proven in court and the real estate agents have not filed their defence statement.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin A collapsed $11.3 million real estate

Bob Mackin

An internal audit of BC Hydro billing found the public utility issued 17,000 refund cheques totalling $7.6 million last year.

The June 5 report, obtained by theBreaker.news under the freedom of information laws, said 87% of refunds were under $600. The largest refund was $187,000 to a commercial customer.

BC Hydro has 2 million customer accounts, of which 1.8 million are residential. For the 10 months ended Jan. 31, it received $1.67 billion revenue from residential customers and $1.596 billion from light industrial and commercial customers.

BC Hydro headquarters (BC Hydro)

The audit was the first of its type since 2011 and happened after the May 1, 2018 expiry of BC Hydro’s contract with Accenture, which handled billing, operations and technology after a controversial 2003 outsourcing deal under the BC Liberal government. It was supposed to cost $1.45 billion over a decade, but, by the sixth year, BC Hydro had already paid $1.17 billion.

The new audit found the majority of bills were automatically produced on a daily basis using actual meter readings or accurate estimates, but the potential for fraud and gaps in controls mean procedures for adjustments and refunds need strengthening. 

The audit said that smart meters improved billing accuracy and most bills were generated without manual intervention.

“Controls are in place to ensure customer and meter data inputs are accurate and timely,” the audit said. “However a small number of communicating meters are not being billed due to account data input errors with some resulting in revenue loss.”

In January 2019, there were 253 communicating meters outstanding for more than 90 days and not billed. More recent numbers include approximately 100 meters outstanding for over 90 days.

“A reconciliation is not in place to ensure all scheduled meter readings are received and invoiced, and all exceptions are addressed for billing completeness.”

Itron OpenWay smart meter (BC Hydro)

Approximately 2 million smart meters are installed and there have been no major interface failures in the past 12 months. Meter readings are received and stored three times each day, which enables billing for 50,000 to 80,000 meter readings over a 20-day cycle.

Meanwhile, results of a BC Hydro employee engagement survey by PWC found the 5,000 respondents are split on whether to trust those atop the Crown corporation.

“Only 54% of employees in operations trust that executive leadership will do what they say they will. do,” said the report to BC Hydro’s executive team. “This score has improved 5% since last year, but still shows an opportunity for clear communications and engagement that will build the trust within this business group.”

Forty-one percent of those surveyed complained about poor, inefficient or broken processes, 39% said there were inadequate staffing levels and 25% cited a lack of clarity around the decision-making process.

When asked if they would feel comfortable speaking up, without fear of retaliation, if they witnessed disrespectful behaviour at work (such as exclusion, harassment, bullying), 11% said no.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin An internal audit of BC Hydro

Bob Mackin

Ellis Ross, the BC Liberal LNG critic, reported more than $9,000 in sponsored travel on his annual disclosure statement.

According to documents obtained by theBreaker.news from the Clerk’s Office, National Bank provided $7,177.65 for the Skeena MLA’s flights, accommodation and taxi fares for Dec. 3-4, 2018 events in New York and Toronto. Ross spoke on “how LNG approval is achieved in B.C., specifically with First Nations,” according to his annual conflict of interest disclosure statement.

Ellis Ross’s ad on CFTK TV (CFTK)

Ross, the former chief councillor of the Haisla First Nation, also appeared at the “Stand on Guard Edmonton” event on May 17 about LNG approval in B.C. The $1,158.57 in flights and accommodation was paid by Art Lucier, a social conservative Metis Christian evangelist with Kelowna-based Harvest Church.

Ross was also invited to speak on First Nations economy, title issues and major project development at the Canada Action Rally during the Global Petroleum Show in Calgary on June 11. He received $664.91 in airfare and ground transportation from DMG Events.

Anne Kang, the NDP Parliamentary Secretary for Seniors and Multiculturalism, received $1,365.61 in flights and accommodation to the Top 10 Overseas Youth Award in Taiwan.

Agriculture Minister Lana Popham received two tickets to the Power to Be “Natural Gala” Fundraiser valued at $500 on July 12 from Power to Be. She also attended the Legislative Agricultural Chairs Summit in Calgary, July 14-16, and reported $786.90 in accommodation and hospitality from the State Agriculture and Rural Leaders.

John Horgan shooting a selfie with fellow rugby sevens fans at the 2019 Canada Sevens in B.C. Place Stadium. (Mackin)

Premier John Horgan received a free ticket to last March’s Canada Sevens World Rugby Sevens at B.C. Place Stadium, but he did not use his invitation to the halftime reception.

Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation Minister Scott Fraser reported receiving a $750 paddle from Nanwakolas and Knight Inlet, a $750 paddle from the We Wai Kai First Nation and a $750 buckskin vest from Tsilquot’in National Government. Jinny Sims received a similar $750 carved paddle from the Nanwakolas, while Environment Minister George Heyman received a handcrafted drum from a First Nation elder at the Burgoyne Bay Provincial Park.

Jobs and Trade Minister Bruce Ralston received a $300 ticket to the Consul General of Italy gourmet dinner on Nov. 23, 2018.

Richmond South Centre Liberal MLA Linda Reid reported two tickets worth $1,000 to the Richmond Hospital Foundation Gala, Oct. 27, 2018 from the Richmond Hospital Foundation.

Thirteen MLAs disclosed that they scored free passes to games at the World Junior Hockey Championship.

Click each name below to access MLA’s annual disclosure statements.

Abbotsford South Darryl Plecas

Abbotsford West Mike de Jong

Abbotsford-Mission Simon Gibson

Boundary-Similkameen Linda Larson

Burnaby North Janet Routledge

Burnaby-Deer Lake Anne Kang

Burnaby-Edmonds Raj Chouhan

Burnaby-Lougheed Katrina Chen

Cariboo Chilcotin Donna Barnett

Cariboo North Coralee Oakes

Chilliwack John Martin

Chilliwack-Kent Laurie Throness

Columbia River-Revelstoke Doug Clovechok

Coquitlam-Burke Mountain Joan Isaacs

Coquitlam-Maillardville Selina Robinson

Courtenay-Comox Ronna-Rae Leonard

Cowichan Valley Sonia Furstenau

Delta North Ravi Kahlon

Delta South Ian Paton

Esquimalt-Metchosin Mitzi Dean

Fraser-Nicola Jackie Tegart

Kamloops-North Thompson Peter Milobar

Kamloops-South-Thompson Todd Stone

Kelowna West Ben Stewart

Kelowna-Lake Country Norm Letnick

Kelowna-Mission Steve Thomson

Kootenay East Tom Shypitka

Kootenay West Katrine Conroy

Langford-Juan de Fuca John Horgan

Langley Mary Polak

Langley East Rich Coleman

Maple-Ridge Mission Bob D’Eith

Maple Ridge-Pitt Meadows Lisa Beare

Mid Island-Pacific Rim Scott Fraser

Nanaimo Sheila Malcolmson

Nanaimo-North Cowichan Doug Routley

Nechako Lakes John Rustad

Nelson-Creston Michelle Mungall

New Westminster Judy Darcy

North Coast Jennifer Rice

North Island Claire Trevena

North Vancouver-Lonsdale Bowinn Ma

North Vancouver-Seymour Jane Thornthwaite

Oak Bay-Gordon Head Andrew Weaver

Parksville-Qualicum Michelle Stilwell

Peace River North Dan Davies

Peace River South Mike Bernier

Penticton Dan Ashton

Port Coquitlam Mike Farnworth

Port Moody-Coquitlam Rick Glumac

Powell River-Sunshine Coast Nicholas Simons

Prince George-Mackenzie Mike Morris

Prince George-Valemount Shirley Bond

Richmond North Centre Teresa Wat

Richmond South Centre Linda Reid

Richmond-Queensborough Jas Johal

Richmond-Steveston John Yap

Saanich North and the Islands Adam Olsen

Saanich South Lana Popham

Shuswap Greg Kyllo

Skeena Ellis Ross

Stikine Doug Donaldson

Surrey South Stephanie Cadieux

Surrey-Cloverdale Marvin Hunt

Surrey-Fleetwood Jagrup Brar

Surrey-Green Timbers Rachna Singh

Surrey-Guildford Garry Begg

Surrey-Newton Harry Bains

Surrey-Panorama Jinny Sims

Surrey-Whalley Bruce Ralston

Surrey-White Rock Tracy Redies

Vancouver-Fairview George Heyman

Vancouver-False Creek Sam Sullivan

Vancouver-Fraserview George Chow

Vancouver-Hastings Shane Simpson

Vancouver-Kensington Mable Elmore

Vancouver-Kingsway Adrian Dix

Vancouver-Langara Michael Lee

Vancouver-Mount Pleasant Melanie Mark

Vancouver-Point Grey David Eby

Vancouver-Quilchena Andrew Wilkinson

Vancouver-West End Spencer Chandra Herbert

Vernon-Monashee Eric Foster

Victoria-Beacon Hill Carole James

Victoria-Swan Lake Rob Fleming

West Vancouver-Capilano Ralph Sultan

West Vancouver-Sea-to-Sky Jordan Sturdy

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin Ellis Ross, the BC Liberal LNG

Bob Mackin

The new driveway at the Parliament Buildings is going over its $1.5 million budget.

The Legislative Assembly Management Committee voted Dec. 3 to spend another $255,000, after the executive financial officer, Hilary Woodward, delivered the bad news.

Driveway construction at the Parliament Buildings (Mackin)

Woodward said digging up the 109-year-old driveway revealed contaminated soil, though she did not say what contaminants were found. That cost another $200,000 for the testing and removal. Old pipes containing asbestos were also found. Existing waterlines needed to be lowered and electrical repairs undertaken.

“It’s not just the replacement of the driveway itself,” Woodward said in the meeting. “We were able to take that opportunity and do a lot of underground infrastructure and put it in place, including a conduit for lighting for future projects as well.”

By email, Acting Clerk Kate Ryan-Lloyd told theBreaker.news that two pipes buried in a shallow concrete trench tested positive for asbestos. The area was immediately taped-off and visitors and staff banned from the area. Sixteen of 50 test hole locations turned up contaminated or hazardous materials. Fourteen of them contained chlorides at levels exceeding Ministry of Environment thresholds. Lead was found in one test hole and barium in another, both at levels exceeding Ministry of Environment guidelines.

Meanwhile, the proposed Legislative Assembly operating budget for next fiscal year is $85 million, a $2 million increase over the current year.

Ryan-Lloyd said the additional funds would improve the workplace environment, with enhanced staff engagement, training and development, labour relations initiatives, a respectful workplace policy and creation of a whistleblower policy.

The committee is also requesting $6 million for capital funding, a decrease of $224,000 from the previous year. The focus is safety, security and infrastructure improvements.

Ryan-Lloyd’s report to the committee also summarized a series of transparency measures. The Legislative Assembly is now publicly reporting quarterly the expenses and compensation for executive staff and travel spending by all assembly staff. There are also new disclosure provisions for transition payments to retired or defeated MLAs and the online posting of MLA conflict of interest disclosure statements. The next wave of proactive disclosure categories could include procurement contracts, purchasing card transactions, and interparliamentary visits, exchanges and conferences.

Speaker Darryl Plecas (left), interim clerk Kate Ryan-Lloyd last January. (Mackin)

The measures are a stop-gap until the NDP government fulfils promises made earlier this year to place the Legislative Assembly under the freedom of information laws. The promise was made by NDP Government House Leader Mike Farnworth in the wake of Speaker Darryl Plecas’s report on corruption in the offices of the Clerk and Sergeant-at-Arms. Craig James and Gary Lenz both retired in disgrace and are under RCMP investigation.

Also stemming from Plecas’s investigation, the Legislature has instituted new policies for purchasing cards, travel, liquor, uniforms, standards of conduct, gifts and even a policy on creating and updating policies.

Polices are either under review or development for asset disposal, hospitality, legal assistance, parking, retirement allowance, vacation and whistleblowers.

The Legislative Assembly is also playing catch-up with modern human resources strategies. Ryan-Lloyd said there are now regular meetings with senior management. A management seminar was held, as was a full, organization-wide staff meeting. For the first time, the Legislative Assembly conducted a staff survey.

“We’ve had employee suggestion boxes, coffee drop-in sessions and as we look ahead to the new year,” Ryan-Lloyd said. “I hope to continue those efforts and do everything we can to sustain ongoing staff engagement as well as provide new training and development opportunities for legislative staff and improve our human resource management practices.”

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin The new driveway at the Parliament