Recent Posts
Connect with:
Sunday / March 9.
  • No products in the cart.
HomeStandard Blog Whole Post (Page 117)

For the week of Sept. 5, 2021:

He is one of Canada’s two most-famous Michaels, held hostage in China for 1,000 days.

Yet few have heard his voice, until now.

Balazs Sarkadi of Michael Kovrig’s former punk band Bankrupt (Bankrupt.hu)

While living in Budapest in 1999, Michael Kovrig recorded the single “Listen” with his Bankrupt bandmates for a punk compilation album.

On this edition of theBreaker.news Podcast, hear that song and Bankrupt’s 2021 single, “The Plane to Toronto,” recorded for the campaign to free the Two Michaels.

Kovrig’s former bandmate Balazs Sarkadi joins host Bob Mackin to recount Kovrig’s return to stage with Bankrupt in 2017. Kovrig visited the capital of Hungary, the year before China kidnapped him and Michael Spavor in retaliation for Canada’s arrest of Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou.

Sarkadi said it was surreal when he heard the news of his friend’s arrest and believed it was a misunderstanding that would be sorted out in a few days or maybe weeks. But then months became years. The turning point was Kovrig’s secret trial in March.

“After a while this song was born, The Plane to Toronto,” Sarkadi said. “I wanted to catch that moment when he is finally released and gets on the plane going home, and I wanted to sort of send some positive energy out there that this is going to happen.”

Also, hear from Troy Clifford, head of the Ambulance Paramedics of B.C., on the shocking anti-vaccine protests at B.C. hospitals, and Kailin Che, the Conservative candidate in Vancouver-Granville on Liberal candidate Taleeb Noormohamed’s real estate flipping scandal.

Plus commentary and Pacific Rim and Pacific Northwest headlines.

CLICK BELOW to listen or go to TuneIn or Apple Podcasts.

Now on Google Podcasts!

Have you missed an edition of theBreaker.news Podcast? Go to the archive.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast: Budapest punk band wants China to listen and free ex-singer Michael Kovrig
Loading
/

For the week of Sept. 5, 2021:

Bob Mackin

A trio of Trudeau Liberal MPs seeking re-election on Sept. 20 headlined a British Properties garden party that drew familiar faces from provincial and federal backrooms. 

Judi Tyabji and Mark Marissen attended the Sept. 2 event in support of Terry Beech (Burnaby-North Seymour), Jonathan Wilkinson (North Vancouver) and Patrick Weiler (West Vancouver-Sunshine Coast-Sea-to-Sky Country).

Judi Tyabji at a Sept. 2 Liberal supporters’ garden party (Facebook)

Tyabji and Marissen were on Christy Clark’s inner circle when the BC Liberals lost their majority in the May 2017 election and lost power to the NDP in the June 2017 confidence vote. Marissen’s Burrard Strategy produced Weiler’s 2019 campaign promotional video. He is running for Mayor of Vancouver in 2022 and his supporters include Clark, his ex-wife.

Tyabji co-founded Salish Sea Spirits Powell River distillery in 2019 and Brew Bay Luxury Wellness in 2020. Notably absent from the garden party: her 1994-wed husband Gordon Wilson.

Weiler is facing a challenge from John Weston, the Conservative MP from 2008 to 2015. Weston’s predecessor was Blair Wilson, who was elected as a Liberal in 2006 but lost as a Green in 2008 after a Province newspaper exposé about his restaurant businesses. 

Blair Wilson named Tyabji and Marissen among the defendants in a long-running defamation suit against the newspaper. At the time, Marissen was the party’s national campaign co-chair and Tyabji the Powell River riding association vice-president. Wilson dropped his claims against Marissen when the trial began in 2015. The 2017 judgment dismissed claims against Tyabji.

Tyabji published a photo of the garden party on Instagram and Facebook including prominent Liberal supporter Farouk Verjee. Verjee is president of investment and commercial real estate brokerage Chase Realty Corp. and an Ismaili Muslim community leader. 

Karimah es Sabar with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau (LPC/Quark)

Garden party host Karimah es Sabar is another longtime Justin Trudeau and Aga Khan follower. Sabar was named in June 2020 to the Liberal government’s Industry Strategy Council to represent the health and biosciences industries.

The former CEO of the Centre for Drug Research and Development at the University of B.C. joined Quark Venture LP in 2016 when the venture capital firm partnered with the GF Securities investment bank of China in a US$500 million fund.

Quark and GF are also affiliated with the Chengdu, China-based Global Drug Commercialization Center.

A person familiar with Sabar’s event said invitees were not asked to make a political donation. They were asked whether they had symptoms of COVID-19, had traveled out of country in the last two weeks or had knowingly been in contact with a coronavirus patient. 

However, they were not asked for their vaccination status.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin A trio of Trudeau Liberal MPs

Bob Mackin

A group collecting signatures for an Elections BC-approved petition to force a referendum on Surrey’s cop swap had a surprise visitor on Sept. 4.

Surrey Mayor Doug McCallum (right) arguing with Ivan Scott of the Keep the RCMP in Surrey campaign on Sept. 4 outside a Save-On-Foods (photo submitted)

Mayor Doug McCallum, the man behind the drive to replace the RCMP with the Surrey Police Service.

Merle Scott of Keep the RCMP in Surrey said her group was set-up outside the Save-on-Foods store in the South Point mall in South Surrey with permission of store management when McCallum arrived around 10 a.m.

Scott said he told the signature collectors they did not have permission to be on-site and threatened to call bylaw officers to remove them.

“I said you can’t do that, you don’t even know your own laws,” Scott told theBreaker.news. “You cannot kick us off here, you don’t have permission.”

A photograph was taken of McCallum exchanging words with Scott’s husband Ivan Scott.

Merle Scott said McCallum also falsely accused another person of driving over his foot.

She said McCallum was there for approximately 10 minutes, including the time spent inside the store where it is believed he spoke to staff. She wonders why McCallum is so worried about the petition if he is so sure the Surrey Police Service will eventually replace the RCMP.

Scott said McCallum arrived and left in his taxpayer-funded Buick SUV.

A 6:51 p.m., Sept. 5 email sent from McCallum’s personal address said: “You do not know the true circumstances of this incident and it is currently under serious police investigation.”

McCallum did not respond to an email seeking more information and an interview.

Just before 5 p.m. on Sept. 6, his spokeswoman Amber Stowe sent a prepared statement by email attributed to McCallum. It said: “I was verbally assaulted and then run over by a vehicle while out grocery shopping yesterday. It is now under police investigation and I am doing okay.”

Elections BC set Nov. 15 as the deadline to sign-up 10% of registered voters in all of B.C.’s 87 ridings to trigger a referendum. The campaign, registered to Darlene Bennett, is focusing on Surrey ridings only and hopes to sign up enough citizens that the NDP cabinet will schedule a referendum anyway.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin A group collecting signatures for an

Bob Mackin

Aggressive coyotes are getting all the attention in Stanley Park this summer.

But the Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure’s turtle-slow reaction has put Stanley Park Causeway motorists and cyclists in danger of serious injury.

Stanley Park Causeway safety railings on July 3. Still not fixed in early September. (Mackin)

A May 31 crash wiped out a section of the causeway’s wired pedestrian railings.

As of Sept. 1, it has still not been replaced.

The Ministry told theBreaker.news that its maintenance contractor has parts stockpiled for incidents, but there were not enough parts on hand to repair the damaged section.

“The pieces are on order and are being fabricated locally, and the section of safety fencing will be repaired as soon as the pieces are ready.” 

Instead of a gap, the section has makeshift barriers, tape and pylons. None of which would withstand a high velocity vehicle or bike crash.

Stanley Park Causeway crash in August 2020 (Reddit.com)

At one end, an orange traffic pylon is all that covers what remains of one of the horizontal rail bars that is near eye-level for thousands of motorists that pass-by daily.

In August 2020, a U-Haul van crashed into one of the barriers and the driver narrowly missed being impaled.

The best the Ministry can do for the time being is express apologies for the delay, and ask cyclists to use caution and drivers to operate vehicles with care.

Stanley Park Causeway safety railings on July 3. Still not fixed in early September. (Mackin)

Taxpayer and construction-funded cycling lobby HUB successfully campaigned for the barriers on the 2.2 kilometre Causeway’s curbs after a cyclist fell in front of a West Vancouver Blue Bus and died in May 2013.

The province spent $4.4 million on the project that included widening sidewalks and the logging of 14 trees.

Documents obtained by theBreaker.news under freedom of information show that it cost more than $18,000 to repair the railings and cables after three crashes between Jan. 1, 2019 and Sept. 23, 2019. More than half the cost was for replacement of eight top rails and 20 stainless steel cables in one June 2019 incident.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

 

 

Bob Mackin Aggressive coyotes are getting all the

Bob Mackin

The Trudeau Liberal candidate in Vancouver Granville grossed a six-figure profit from buying and selling condos near Winter Olympic venues while he worked as a vice-president of the Vancouver 2010 organizing committee, theBreaker.news has learned.

Taleeb Noormohamed during his vice-presidency with VANOC (Vince Fedoroff/Ismailimail)

Property records show Taleeb Noormohamed bought five Vancouver properties from the end of June 2007 to late November 2009. Four were condominiums within a short walk of downtown venues for Olympic hockey and ceremonies.

One was in a tower developed by Olympics sponsor Concord Pacific above the Costco across from Games hockey venue Rogers Arena. He bought for $297,000 in February 2008 and sold for $314,900 in November 2009. A $17,900 profit.

On the same day as that sale, Noormohamed bought a Yaletown condo for $425,000, which he unloaded for $449,000, a $24,000 gross profit, after the Games in April 2010.

Noormohamed also bought a condo for $440,000 on Main Street in June 2007. The Russian government rented nearby Science World to promote the 2014 Olympics in Sochi. In March 2011, Noormohamed sold the unit for $475,000, a $35,000 gross profit.

Noormohamed’s gross profit for the transactions between August 2009 and March 2011 was $105,000.

But a property data spreadsheet, released by the NDP, does not show whether Noormohamed also generated rental income during his 2007 to 2010 tenure as vice-president of strategy and partnerships for the Vancouver 2010 Olympic organizing committee, also known as VANOC.

Noormohamed worked with the office of CEO John Furlong on a variety of files, including national and international client services and the sale of sponsorship packages to provincial and territorial governments.

In the years before the 2010 Games, downtown accommodation scarcity was a major worry of civic governments and Games organizers. Some of the pressure subsided in the fall of 2008 when the Great Recession caused several major sponsors to cut back on hotel reservations.

theBreaker.news wanted to ask Noormohamed questions about his real estate activities and whether he disclosed any of that to his superiors at VANOC.

Concord Pacific’s 131 Regiment Square tower near Rogers Arena. (Google maps)

He did not respond to phone or email messages.

Noormohamed was the losing Liberal candidate in 2011 in North Vancouver and 2019 in Vancouver Granville.

Jesse Bartsoff, who is on election leave from being an aide to Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland, sent a prepared statement on behalf of Noormohamed.

“I am fully committed to making housing more affordable across Canada, and right here at home in Vancouver Granville,” said the statement attributed to Noormohamed. “Last week, Prime Minister Trudeau announced the most ambitious plan of any party to make housing more affordable – and I will work hard to make that plan a reality. While I have had business activities improving homes, I have been consistent in my support for measures to make housing more affordable, and as the MP for Vancouver Granville, it will remain a priority.”

theBreaker.news pressed Bartsoff further to arrange an interview, but he replied: “Mr. Noormohamed is unavailable for comment beyond our previous statement.”

During his time with VANOC, Noormohamed had access to considerable insider information about Olympic accommodation needs. He was also subject to internal conflict of interest disclosure policies and procedures, according to the organization’s last sustainability report in late 2010.

“Senior managers were also required to file such documentation, only once, in 2008, though with a requirement that they proactively update their original filing if their circumstances changed,” the report said. “This process identified potential conflicts while sending a strong message to the entire workforce about how VANOC conducted business.”

It is not possible to independently verify whether Noormohamed disclosed his condo transactions near Olympic venues or whether he derived any rental income. VANOC transferred its corporate archives to the City of Vancouver Archives after the Games and the parties agreed to prohibit public access to Vancouver 2010 board and committee minutes, financial records and legal correspondence until the fall of 2025.

The red pin is where Taleeb Normoohamed bought a condo in late 2009, on the day he sold one near Rogers Arena. (Google maps)

After the Games, Noormohamed was vice-president of global development for vacation rental company HomeAway from 2012 to 2015. Expedia acquired HomeAway and merged it last year with VRBO, the main competitor of Airbnb.

The spreadsheet shows Noormohamed made $4.922 million in gross profits on 46 residential transactions since 2002 — nearly $3.7 million of that came in the last six years.

He bought and sold 21 properties in the space of a single year and currently holds five properties, including one worth $2.2 million in the Altamont neighbourhood of West Vancouver near the home of John Weston, the former Harper Conservative MP who is attempting a comeback.

None of Noormohamed’s five properties is in Vancouver Granville. 

Peter Julian, who was the NDP house leader until the election, called Trudeau’s promised anti-flipping tax “empty” because the Liberals did nothing to crack down on speculators or control prices since coming to power in 2015.

“Was [Trudeau] aware of [Noormohamed’s] house-flipping when he signed his candidate’s nomination papers and is he OK with that fact that this candidate for parliament has made millions of dollars by flipping dozens of houses?” Julian asked during an Aug. 30 news conference outside one of the condos Noormohamed flipped.

Anjali Appadurai, the NDP candidate in Vancouver Granville, said what Noormohamed did “may be legal, but it is predatory and it shouldn’t be legal.”

Election day is Sept. 20.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

 

Bob Mackin The Trudeau Liberal candidate in Vancouver

For the week of Aug. 29, 2021:

The big announcement from Vancouver city hall this summer was the hiring of its first auditor general, Michael McDonnell. On this edition of theBreaker.news Podcast, hear from Colleen Hardwick, the councillor behind the establishment of the waste and corruption-fighting office.

Host Bob Mackin asks Coun. Hardwick about budget and livability challenges facing Vancouver as the one-year countdown to the October 2022 civic election campaign is just around the corner. 

Plus commentary and Pacific Rim and Pacific Northwest headlines.

CLICK BELOW to listen or go to TuneIn or Apple Podcasts.

Now on Google Podcasts!

Have you missed an edition of theBreaker.news Podcast? Go to the archive.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast: Catching-up with Councillor Colleen
Loading
/

For the week of Aug. 29, 2021:

Bob Mackin

A presentation to a senior bureaucrat in the B.C. NDP government suggests bidders for the 2030 Winter Olympics and Paralympics are eager to negotiate a backroom deal to bring the Games back to Vancouver.

John Furlong (left) and RCMP Olympic security head Bud Mercer in 2010 (BudMercer.ca)

theBreaker.news exclusively obtained a copy of a March 17 Powerpoint presentation by John Furlong, the Vancouver 2010 organizing committee CEO, to Assistant Deputy Tourism, Arts and Culture Minister Asha Bhat.

Twice in the BC 2030-branded presentation there are references to preferred candidate status.

The International Olympic Committee is facing a shortage of Games host cities due to spiralling costs and corruption scandals. New IOC policies seek to replace expensive bidding wars with negotiations aimed at the early awarding of hosting rights.

In February, the IOC named Brisbane the preferred candidate for the 2032 Summer Games. In July, before the Summer Olympics opened in Tokyo, the IOC rubber-stamped the Australian city as the host, four years before the scheduled host city vote.

Under the heading “winning conditions,” the BC 2030 presentation states: “New IOC process is simplified and tailored for an existing Host City to bring the Games home again.”

“Opportunity to achieve preferred candidate status; 2034 will have increased competition,” said the presentation. “The timing may never again be this favourable for Canada to win.”

It identified potential competitors as 1972-host Sapporo and 2002-host Salt Lake City, both of whom could be adversely impacted by Summer Olympics in their countries: Tokyo 2020 and Los Angeles 2028.

The presentation said a European bid is unlikely, but a group is exploring a joint Spanish/French/Andorran Games for 2030.

From BC 2030 bid presentation to the Ministry of Tourism, Arts and Culture (BC Gov/FOI)

The BC 2030 presentation suggests three hosting concepts, none of which carry cost estimates:

  • “2010 Model”: Reuse Vancouver 2010 venues, with the exception of the Hillcrest curling complex (now a community centre) and the Olympic Village (which is fully occupied);
  • “2010 Modified”: Reuse most 2010 venues, but consider including additional communities, such as Victoria and Burnaby; or
  • A regional or provincial Games, with venues across B.C.

The presentation was thin on details, but heavy on platitudes. It claimed the 2030 Games could be the “most sustainable” Winter Games bid ever, carbon-neutral and privately funded. The source of the private funds was not mentioned.

The estimated cost of $2 billion for Games operations does not include building an Olympic Village, renovation or expansion to existing venues or Games-time security. In 2010, the RCMP and Canadian military spent $900 million.

In smaller print, the presentation includes this disclaimer about costs: “Excludes choices governments may make to leverage the Games to invest in infrastructure, community and/or legacy initiatives.”

BC 2030 Olympic bid logo (BC Gov/FOI)

One of the slides claims “very positive” initial conversations with First Nations and “Measured and positive early conversations with Federal Government, Whistler, Richmond, Burnaby, Vancouver.”

Another slide mentions opportunities for housing and transportation mega-projects, specifically the Arbutus to UBC SkyTrain, and suggests the 2010 Four Host First Nations could reunite in 2030 and use the Games to meet goals of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (DRIPA).

Furlong’s BC 2030 bid team includes five former VANOC executives: marketing vice-president Andrea Shaw, sport vice-president Tim Gayda, communications director Chris Brumwell, Games operations managing director Mary Conibear and commercial rights management director Bill Cooper.

Four are consultants, while Brumwell is vice-president of communications with Canucks Sports and Entertainment.

The Aquilini-owned Rogers Arena could be the main hockey venue in a 2030 bid. The owners of the Vancouver Canucks are also hoping to build a new ski resort near Squamish.

The IOC wants to choose the 2030 host no later than 2023, but questions remain about how much VANOC spent on the 2010 Games and who got paid what. Board meeting minutes and financial files remain off-limits to the public until fall 2025, under a post-Games agreement with the City of Vancouver Archives.

Questions also remain about Furlong’s past. His 2011-published Patriot Hearts memoir omitted his past as a gym teacher at a Catholic day school for indigenous children. Six members of the Burns Lake band accused Furlong of child abuse dating back to 1969. None of the allegations has been tested in court. Furlong denied any wrongdoing.

The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal will hear their complaint against the RCMP, which alleges the Furlong file was closed due to anti-indigenous racism and favouritism for Furlong.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin A presentation to a senior bureaucrat

For the week of Aug. 22, 2021:

It’s theBreaker.news Podcast bicentennial edition.

Celebrate the milestone with highlights from the first, 50th, 100th and 150th editions with host Bob Mackin:

  • The first edition on Nov. 5, 2017 featuring investigative reporter Glenn Greenwald’s appearance at the Allard Prize anti-corruption awards;
  • Richmond real estate and immigration lawyer Hong Guo, during her failed 2018 mayoral campaign, denying China’s human rights abuses;
  • From the 100th edition in 2019, corruption-fighting B.C. Legislature Speaker Darryl Plecas and outspoken Port Coquitlam Mayor Brad West;
  • And Sonia Furstenau, before she was elected the B.C. Greens leader and faced the NDP’s John Horgan in his controversial snap election.
  • Plus commentary and Pacific Rim and Pacific Northwest headlines.

CLICK BELOW to listen or go to TuneIn or Apple Podcasts.

Now on Google Podcasts!

Have you missed an edition of theBreaker.news Podcast? Go to the archive.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast: Special 200th edition
Loading
/

For the week of Aug. 22, 2021:

Bob Mackin

Vancouver Whitecaps FC returns Aug. 21 to play in front of a B.C. Place crowd for the first time since the pandemic began.

The date is also nine months after a judge ruled the Major League Soccer club could not keep its stadium lease a secret anymore.

Whitecaps’ captain Jay DeMerit (left) and Premier Christy Clark at the Sept. 30, 2011 reopening of B.C. Place Stadium (Whitecaps)

theBreaker.news originally sought a copy of the amendment in fall 2016 from B.C. Pavilion Corporation under the freedom of information law. PavCo and the Whitecaps refused to co-operate.

In early 2019, an adjudicator with the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner upheld the public’s right to access negotiated contracts between private companies and public bodies. But the Whitecaps sued the OIPC to block the disclosure.

The club unsuccessfully claimed the deal with the taxpayer-owned stadium manager was not negotiated and admitted it did not want the public to know the financial and sponsorship terms.

B.C. Place Stadium was supposed to become Telus Park, but Clark nixed the naming rights deal.

B.C. Supreme Court Justice Karen Horsman disagreed with the Whitecaps and ruled: “The adjudicator’s decision was justified, intelligible and transparent, and therefore reasonable.”

theBreaker.news finally got a copy of the Jan. 1, 2017-effective sponsorship agreement, which is an addendum to the 15-year anchor tenancy deal made March 10, 2011.

The reason for the deal was to resolve a long-simmering feud over naming rights.

The Whitecaps sought the amendment for advertising and sponsorship activations outside of the stadium’s inner bowl.

PavCo retained the right to sell naming rights for the stadium itself, but committed to engaging with the Whitecaps on the issue “in a collaborative and integrated manner.”

Whitecaps’ owner Greg Kerfoot (Santa Ono, Twitter)

Before the September 2011 reopening from a $563 million renovation, PavCo sold the naming rights to Telus for $40 million in cash, goods and services over 20 years. But the Telus Park sign was never raised.

The BC Liberal cabinet under Premier Christy Clark, a close friend of Whitecaps’ owner Greg Kerfoot, cancelled the deal under pressure from the Bell-sponsored Whitecaps. PavCo paid $15 million for screens and wifi installed by Telus.

Whitecaps have referred to the field under the roof as Bell Pitch, but PavCo began seeking a new naming rights partner a year before the pandemic hit.

The contract, obtained exclusively by theBreaker.news, set the Whitecaps’ annual payments to PavCo at $225,000 (or $12,500-per-game) from 2017 to 2021. The payments increase by $25,000-per year beginning in 2022, maxing out at $325,000 in 2025.

The deal also hiked the facility fee to $3.25 per ticket and the parties agreed to a comprehensive review of facility fees during the 2021 operating year.

In the mid-2000s, Kerfoot proposed building his own $75 million outdoor stadium north of Gastown. He did not contribute to the cost of the B.C. Place renovation, which included a retractable roof. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

 

READ: Whitecaps contract with B.C. Pavilion Corporation by Bob Mackin on Scribd

Bob Mackin Vancouver Whitecaps FC returns Aug. 21

Bob Mackin

Opponents of the fledgling Surrey Police Service discovered in documents released under freedom of information that Chief Norm Lipinski uses a private email account while doing public business.

But when they posted to Twitter an excerpt from Lipinski’s email that contained his Gmail address, the non-operational police department convinced the social media company to suspend the Keep the RCMP in Surrey [KTRIS] account and delete the Tweet.

The Tweet that led to a lawsuit threat from Surrey Police Service (KTRIS/Twitter)

When they tried to repost it, SPS retained a lawyer to threaten two KTRIS supporters with a lawsuit.

The Aug. 18 cease and desist letter from Keri Bennett, a workplace privacy lawyer at the Roper Greyell firm in Vancouver, accused them of trying to “unlawfully use and distribute [Lipinski’s] personal email address.”

theBreaker.news wanted to know why Lipinski uses a foreign-owned, web-based email account for police business. He did not respond Aug. 19.

Coun. Brenda Locke of Surrey Connect, who opposes Mayor Doug McCallum’s slow-moving switch from the RCMP, said Lipinski is in the wrong.

“He’s a police chief and he should be using proper protocol, which is not to use a personal account,” Locke said. “I’m puzzled as to why they’re going after — with citizens’ money, by the way — going after residents for something was provided to them by the very police service itself.”

Paul Daynes, spokesman for Keep the RCMP in Surrey, said the group considers the cease and desist letter “bullying and intimidation of the most-unacceptable kind” toward the senior women who obtained the documents under the FOI law.

“We are currently considering lodging a formal complaint with the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner [OIPC] and the Office of the Police Complaints Commissioner [OPCC] for B.C. for conduct unbecoming and unacceptable in a senior police officer for the province,” Daynes said.

Surrey Police Chief Norm Lipinski.

It is not illegal for a public official to use a private email address. But the OIPC considers all work-related communications by public officials subject to the freedom of information law. An email address used for business purposes is not personal information.

“The use of personal email accounts does not relieve public bodies of their duty to comprehensively search for requested records and to produce them,” then-OIPC Commissioner Elizabeth Denham declared in a March 2013 directive to appointed and elected officials. “The use of personal email accounts for work purposes can give the perception that public body employees are seeking to evade the freedom of information process.”

Denham’s statement also reminded public officials that a personal email account is a security risk.

Coun. Brenda Locke (Surrey Connect)

First, the terms of service for personal accounts may allow third-party access to content in a way that is in contravention of FIPPA. Second, security features for webmail services may not be adequate for FIPPA purposes. Any public body that allows use of personal email accounts to send or receive personal information is therefore risking non-compliance with FIPPA,” Denham wrote.

Surrey NDP MLA Jinny Sims stepped down in October 2019 from her cabinet post as the minister in charge of the B.C. government’s freedom of information department after she was caught using personal accounts to bypass the FOI system.

In 2018, during his final term as Mayor of Vancouver, theBreaker.news revealed that Gregor Robertson was using a Gmail account to hide his communications — including Tweets that were ghostwritten by his chief of staff.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin Opponents of the fledgling Surrey Police