Recent Posts
Connect with:
Wednesday / January 15.
  • No products in the cart.
HomeStandard Blog Whole Post (Page 73)

Bob Mackin

The International Olympic Committee indefinitely postponed the selection of a 2030 Winter Olympics host on Dec. 6, but that is not enough to change the B.C. government’s mind. 

“The Ministry was made aware this morning of the International Olympics Committee’s decision to delay the awarding of the 2030 Winter Games,” said a statement from the Ministry of Tourism, Art, Culture and Sport. “Cabinet reviewed the hosting proposal earlier this fall and decided not to support this bid, given the significant investment and risks involved. The Province’s decision is binding and will not be revisited.”

IOC Games executive director Christophe Dubi (IOC/YouTube)

The IOC was originally expected to use this week’s executive board meetings at headquarters in Lausanne, Switzerland to open negotiations with Salt Lake City and Sapporo, Japan. In late October, the NDP government opted against underwriting the bid involving the Canadian Olympic Committee and Four Host First Nations — Musqueam, Squamish, Tsleil-Waututh and Lil’wat. 

Instead, the IOC executive board announced that it agreed with the Future Host Commission’s proposal to take more time to study the impacts of climate change on future Winter Games, the possibility of rotating hosts from a pool of cities and requiring those cities to use only existing or temporary venues. 

In a teleconference with reporters, an Olympics executive did not provide a new deadline. 

“It will enable the commission to consult deeply with interested parties, of course, but also International Federations, National Olympic Committees, the athletes, the winter sport industry experts, the [International Paralympic Committee], because, yes, we are operating over a month,” said Christophe Dubi, the IOC’s executive director of the Games. “So it’s that full month [of competition] that needs to be considered in a global warming environment.”

The decision on 2030 had already been delayed from May 2023 to fall 2023, due to postponement of the annual IOC meetings scheduled for Mumbai.

The effort to bring the Olympics back to 2010 host Vancouver hit a wall in late October when the NDP government said it had other vital spending priorities and would not fulfil the IOC-required duty of deficit liability. The federal sport hosting policy firmly states that Ottawa will not guarantee deficit funding. 

“With billions of dollars in direct costs and risks, supporting a 2030 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games bid could jeopardize the Province’s ability to address the very real pressures facing British Columbians,” continued the Ministry’s statement. “Government remains committed to the important work of reconciliation and continuing to build strong relationships with First Nations and Indigenous partners.” 

The Canadian Olympic Committee and Canadian Paralympic Committee feasibility team indicated in a Tuesday statement that it is not finished lobbying for government support. 

“We continue to see value in the opportunity for all partners to come together and fully explore the potential benefits of hosting a 2030 Winter Games in British Columbia, and this decision allows for more time for dialogue amongst parties on the significant amount of work done to date,” said a statement released by the bid group.

Sapporo, which held the Games in 1972, is facing headwinds from the Tokyo 2020 organizing committee’s corruption scandal. Salt Lake City hosted the Games in 2002 and said it could be ready for 2030, but the U.S. Olympic Committee prefers 2034 because of potential sponsorship conflicts with the Los Angeles 2028 Summer Games. 

“There was a discussion about the possible double award for 2030 and 2034, to create stability for winter sport and the Olympic Winter Games,” Dubi said. “At this stage, no conclusion has been reached. It will take several more rounds of discussions.”

BC 2030 Olympic bid logo (BC Gov/FOI)

In the context of the B.C. government’s refusal, Dubi was asked whether the IOC would use the indefinite delay to reconsider whether host cities should carry the burden for security and deficits. He indicated that is not on the table because of the terms of the host city contract and the IOC’s existing commitments to contribute revenue from its sale of global sponsorships and broadcast rights.

“What is clear is that the IOC cannot be responsible for a deficit for which it has no responsibility over. We are taking a number of risks ourselves,” Dubi said. 

He said that the IOC had been clear with B.C., and other parties, on what it can deliver back to cities. 

“The IOC is not in to make money,” he said. “It is raising money to distribute to the rest of the Olympic family, the organizing committees to start with, but the National Olympic Committees the International Federations, because in the end, this is for the benefit of the athletes.”

Another IOC official also acknowledged the delay could open the door to more bids for 2030. 

“The mandate of the commission is to constantly ensure that there will be a healthy pipeline of interest for the future,” said Jacqueline Barrett, the director of the IOC’s Future Olympic Games Hosts office. “So that’s where our door is open every day of the year, for any interest,”

The COC estimated Vancouver 2030 would cost $4 billion, including at least $1 billion from taxpayers. It proposed reusing most of the 2010 venues in Vancouver, Richmond and Whistler, with the exception of the Agrodome for curling, Hastings Racecourse for big air skiing and snowboard jumping and Sun Peaks resort near Kamloops for snowboarding and freestyle skiing. 

The 2010 Games are believed to have cost $8 billion, all-in. The true costs are unknown, because the B.C. Auditor General never did a post-Games study, the organizing committee was not subject to the freedom of information law and its board minutes and financial files won’t be open to the public at the City Archives until fall 2025.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin The International Olympic Committee indefinitely postponed

Bob Mackin 

The COVID-19 pandemic is the biggest, most-disruptive global event to affect the lives of British Columbians since the Second World War. 

So the provincial response to the crisis should elicit a full investigation, right? 

Instead, the NDP government hired three ex-civil servants under strict parameters with a deadline of just over six months and no public hearings. After a lengthy delay, it was finally released on Dec. 2 with little fanfare. Solicitor General Mike Farnworth did not appear in front of TV cameras and the authors weren’t there. 

Here’s what you need to know:

Hands tied 

Terms of reference for reviewers Bob de Faye, Dan Perrin and Chris Trumpy did not allow a review of the decisions made by cabinet and the provincial health officer. They weren’t allowed to make recommendations. Instead, they gave findings.

Mike Farnworth announces $2,000 fines on April 19 (BC Gov)

Ahead of time, under budget

That oft-heard government cliche “on-time, on-budget” didn’t apply here. The review’s deadline was Sept. 30, but it arrived a week early. The ministry did not originally announce a budget. When a reporter asked in September, the ministry said it was $1.715 million. The final cost was $775,000. Part of the reason was lower than expected travel costs, due to a reliance on virtual meetings.

Nine-week delay

The report arrived more than a week-and-a-half before the Oct. 3 reopening of the Legislature. It was finally published just over a week after the last Question Period of the fall session and two weeks since David Eby took over as premier from John Horgan. 

Take out the trash

Reporters got a 1:05 p.m. advisory that Farnworth would be available on a teleconference at 2 p.m. on Friday. The report arrived at 1:17 p.m., meaning just 43 minutes to read 144 pages. 

Asked why it was released on such short notice on a Friday afternoon, Farnworth said: “The day was booked, I think some time ago, in terms on this particular day. It was done in terms of what else was going on this afternoon, and it’s on that basis that the schedule was put together.”

Government Communications and Public Engagement did not employ its usual range of communications tools. It frequently provides media with reports and presentations an hour or two prior to a public announcement, on an embargoed basis. Sometimes with a not-for-attribution briefing by officials. 

Not this time. None of the three co-authors was available. 

Case in point: On Sept. 20, reporters got 22 hours notice of the release of the executive summary of a report into repeat offenders and an invitation to register to receive embargoed documents. Farnworth was one of the officials at the in-person and live-streamed announcement, along with report co-authors Doug LePard and Amanda Butler.

Survey says 

The authors gave better than passing marks overall to government for the pandemic response and said there is room for improvement. The respondents to their March 16-April 20 survey through the government’s govTogetherBC platform were harshly critical. 

“A vast majority of respondents want a review of the actual decisions made to respond to the pandemic, which is beyond the scope of this review,” the report said. “The extreme level of vitriol directed at decision-makers by many respondents was shocking.”

Nearly three-quarters (74%) disagreed with the statements “I trusted COVID-19 information provided by government” and “Overall the B.C. Government managed the pandemic well.” 

Respondents slammed the government for its: failure to admit aerosol transmission of COVID; failure to disclose vaccine risks; inadequate testing levels and unreliable case numbers; demonization of critics and firing of unvaccinated health-care workers; inconsistencies between B.C. positions and other jurisdictions without explanation; and unwillingness to release more about local case numbers.

Farnworth dismissed the online survey results, saying “this was not a statistically relevant sample.” 

Omission and commission 

The report claimed that “Information on personal protective equipment inventories did not exist.”

Provincial Health Services Authority memos and briefing notes released under freedom of information in mid-2020 showed that someone was at least counting the emergency stockpiles. They said that the value of medical equipment, including masks, gloves, eye goggles and hand sanitizer, had dwindled from $5.7 million in July 2013 to just $2.07 million by January 2020. 

“Health authorities’ pandemic supply levels have dwindled or been eliminated on many items across the province. Should a widespread pandemic occur in B.C., the current level of pandemic supplies will likely not meet B.C.’s requirements which may lead to public safety risk,” said one of the February 2020 memos.

The report sugar-coated the relationship between the Ministry of Health and three First Nations: “In early 2021, the PHO and senior government officials sat down with leaders from the Heiltsuk Nation, Tsilquot’in National Government, and member nations of the Nuu-chah-nulth Tribal Council to develop an information-sharing agreement, which was signed in early February of that year.”

In 2020, the three First Nations unsuccessfully appealed directly to Minister Adrian Dix and Dr. Bonnie Henry for details of the spread of the virus in their communities. They said the public interest override in the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act required transparency in a crisis. They went public and ultimately, in December 2020, Information and Privacy Commissioner Michael McEvoy released his ruling.

Dr. Lyne Filiatrault (PoP BC/YouTube)

While McEvoy agreed with them that the FOI law trumps the Public Health Act, he was satisfied the government had released enough information under the law.

Missing from the timeline 

The report included a detailed appendix of select pandemic timeline events from January 2020 to May 2022. There was no mention of the B.C.’s first superspreader, the Pacific Dental Conference from March 5-7, 2020 at the public-owned Vancouver Convention Centre. 

The Oct. 24, 2020 provincial election day is mentioned, but not the campaign that preceded election day. The Sept. 20, 2021 federal election isn’t mentioned. 

Thumbs down

Retired emergency room physician Dr. Lyne Filiatrault of Protect Our Province B.C. said the report lacked true independence and was rife with scope creep. 

“They went outside of assessing the government response, they assessed the pandemic response, based on indicators that in my mind are not the correct indicators and with useless data, which is the data that B.C. has based on under-testing, under-reporting,” Filiatrault said in an interview.

“If we’re going to spend the time, the energy and the money on doing an independent review, there has to be concrete, binding actionable goals. As opposed to this 150 pages, which to me, doesn’t leave me with a lot of clarity as to what is the government going to do with this.”

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin  The COVID-19 pandemic is the biggest,

For the week of Dec. 4, 2022:

Hundreds, if not thousands, of commuters were stuck overnight in gridlock Nov. 29-30 when winter arrived.

New Westminster City Councillor Daniel Fontaine (Zoom)

Why did so many municipalities and the B.C. Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure fail to prepare and respond effectively to a snowstorm that affected bridges and roads vital to so many in the Lower Mainland? 

New Westminster City Councillor Daniel Fontaine remembers the City of Vancouver’s 2008 “Snowmaggedon.” Back then, he was co-publisher of the CityCaucus blog. Fontaine wants the 2022 version, that affected many more, to be the last. His solution? Begin with a “snow summit” to bring politicians and senior staff together to determine what went wrong and how they can do right the next time.

Fontaine is host Bob Mackin’s guest on this edition of thePodcast.

Plus Pacific Rim and Pacific Northwest headlines and a commentary.

CLICK BELOW to listen or go to TuneIn or Apple Podcasts.

Now on Google Podcasts!

Have you missed an edition of theBreaker.news Podcast? Go to the archive.

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

theBreaker.news Podcast
theBreaker.news Podcast
thePodcast: New West councillor Fontaine wants "Snowmaggedon" 2022 to be the last
Loading
/

For the week of Dec. 4, 2022: Hundreds,

Bob Mackin 

Less than three days after staying in power with a minority government in the 2021 snap election, planning was underway for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s getaway to Tofino.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau (PMO)

Trudeau flew to his favourite Vancouver Island vacation spot Sept. 30, 2021, instead of attending a ceremony on the first national day to remember Indian residential school victims. 

But email between the Prime Minister’s Office and the Department of National Defence office that books government jets shows the original plan was to travel before Truth and Reconciliation Day. 

Email obtained under the access to information law, after a delay of more than 13 months, shows that a person in the PMO, whose name was censored, emailed the 8 Operations Support Squadron at Canadian Forces Base Trenton at 10:11 a.m. Sept. 23, 2021. 

“We are still planning the private trip to Tofino, so the dates are not locked in, but hoping you could provide the [comparable prices] for departure from Ottawa on either 28 or 29 September for Tofino and return on either the 02 or 03 October,” the PMO email said. 

Under government policy, when travel aboard the fleet is for personal reasons, DND asks a travel agent for the lowest possible commercial fare on a comparable flight and an invoice is issued to the traveler.

Four days later, on Sept. 27, 2021, the person in PMO emailed the DND contact, with new travel dates: Sept. 30-Oct. 4. 

The DND quote for lowest comparable fare was $261.57 per person on Westjet between Vancouver and Ottawa and $560.70 per passenger on Pacific Coastal Airlines between Vancouver and Tofino, for a total $822.27 per person. 

DND invoiced the Justin Trudeau and wife Sophie Gregoire Trudeau $1,644.53 on Oct. 16, 2021, which was only a fraction of the cost of the flight. 

Inside a Bombardier Challenger jet.

On Oct. 1, 2021, DND estimated the cost of the round trip at $19,869.90, of which $14,198.90 was fuel and $907.36 food and catering. 

The itinerary showed Ottawa departure at 8:09 a.m. on Truth and Reconciliation Day and Tofino arrival at 10:28 a.m. local time. 

The morning after attending a ceremony in Ottawa, PMO staff originally claimed Trudeau was spending the new federal holiday in the national capital. They were forced to admit where he really was, after images from flight tracking websites hit social media, showing a Canadian Forces Challenger CC-144 jet from the national capital had landed in Tofino.

There were only three passengers on the manifest for the first, fourth and fifth legs of the journey: the Trudeaus and a person whose name was censored. Generally, the Prime Minister travels with an RCMP bodyguard.

The plane did not stay in Tofino. It flew without passengers to Victoria and returned to Tofino Oct. 3. The Trudeaus and the other passenger departed Oct. 4 at 7:24 a.m. and stopped for a half-hour in Vancouver before continuing to Ottawa for a 3:30 p.m. arrival. 

The trip to Tofino was Trudeau’s eighth as Prime Minister. This time, he stayed in a secluded Chesterman Beach estate, rather than a resort hotel. By skipping Truth and Reconciliation Day, Trudeau upset First Nations leaders, including the Tk’emlups te Secwepemc Chief Rosanne Casimir, who invited Trudeau to come in person or send a video greeting if he couldn’t make it. 

During an Oct. 6, 2021 news conference in Ottawa, Trudeau tearfully apologized. 

“Travelling on the 30th was a mistake and I regret it,” he told reporters. 

Pressed for details of how it came about, Trudeau said: “the ‘how it happened’ is far less important than that it happened, which I regret.”

Kamloops Indian Residential School (UBC IRSHDC)

Trudeau was back in Vancouver on Dec. 2 to meet Premier David Eby in Vancouver and attend a photo op for a federal and provincial subsidized childcare program. He headlines a $500-per-ticket cash for access Liberal Party fundraiser in Surrey on Friday night. 

Four of his eight trips to the West Coast in 2022 have included a party fundraiser. One of those trips was an April vacation to Whistler. 

Documents obtained under access to information show that Trudeau charged taxpayers $800,000 for flights aboard government jets to criss-cross the country between May and August of 2019, prior to that year’s scheduled election. The last of Trudeau’s flights during that period cost $54,000 and was built around the production of a Liberal election campaign ad on the Grouse Grind in North Vancouver. 

According to the SherpaReport, which follows the private jet industry, the Bombardier Challenger 600 series CC-144 jet uses 340 gallons per hour of fuel. The Prime Minister’s entourage flew for 142 flight hours from May to August in 2019, meaning the jets used 48,280 gallons or almost 182,000 litres of jet fuel.

In June 2019, Liberal MPs led the House of Commons in a motion to declare a climate change emergency.

An unofficial account on Twitter called @RCAF-VIP keeps track of Canadian government VIP flights. It estimated the Dec. 1 flight carrying Trudeau to Vancouver used 5,130 litres of fuel at a cost of $8,808 and caused 14 tons of carbon dioxide emissions. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin  Less than three days after staying

Bob Mackin

A former member of the Vancouver Whitecaps’ women’s team, who blew the whistle in 2019 on Bob Birarda’s return to coaching, told a House of Commons committee Dec. 1 that two prominent Canadian soccer executives should not be involved when Canada co-hosts the FIFA World Cup in 2026.

Ciara McCormack (Twitter)

Ciara McCormack testified to the all-party Status of Women committee’s hearing on women and girls in sport that there needs to be a judicial inquiry into the Canadian sport system, including a full investigation of the finances and operations of the Canadian Soccer Association.  

“There’s a lot of taxpayer money going into FIFA 2026 and there was so much harm done in our situation that hasn’t been remedied in any capacity,” McCormack testified.

Former women’s national under-20 head coach and Olympic team assistant coach Birarda pleaded guilty last February to sexually assaulting four players between 1988 and 2008. In November, he was sentenced to 16 months in jail. 

McCormack said the roles of former CSA president Victor Montagliani and general secretary Peter Montopoli are particularly problematic, because they were both in power when Birarda was employed in 2008. Montagliani is now a vice-president of FIFA and Montopoli the chief operating officer for the 2026 World Cup matches in Vancouver and Toronto.

“People like this have no place in sport and we need mechanisms to remove them,” McCormack told the committee. “Because what kind of message does it send to reward leaders of taxpayer-funded sport whilst simultaneously covering up child abuse?”

Last July’s report by University of Western Ontario sport law professor Richard McLaren found that instead of acknowledging Birarda’s abuse and firing him in 2008, “Canada Soccer misled players and obfuscated the true reason for his departure: his continued harassment of players and abuse of the power imbalance between Birarda and players on the team. Moreover, the CSA’s failure to terminate Birarda and impose disciplinary sanctions afforded him the opportunity to continue coaching, putting other players at potential risk.”

McCormack’s appearance at the committee came three hours after Canada’s men’s team lost its third and final match at Qatar 2022. Canada, U.S. and Mexico have already qualified as co-hosts to 2026’s 48-nation, 80-match tournament. 

But the number of matches could be increased if some in FIFA have their way. 

FIFA VP Montagliani and president Infantino (Twitter)

U.S. is already committed to hosting 60 matches, with 10 for Canada and 10 for Mexico. But, the Guardian reported that there have been informal talks behind the scenes in Qatar about changing the opening round format from 16 groups of three nations to 12 groups of four nations. That would result in 24 additional first round matches.

More first round matches could benefit both Vancouver’s B.C. Place Stadium and Toronto’s BMO Field, which fall below FIFA’s 60,000 minimum capacity to host a match in the quarter-finals and beyond. But there would be additional costs. City of Toronto is already expecting to spend $290 million, while the B.C. said it could cost up to $260 million. That doesn’t count the federal contribution for security and other costs. 

“We have not received any information from FIFA regarding the possible expansion of the 2026 World Cup,” said Corinna Fillion of the B.C. Ministry of Tourism, Arts, Culture and Sport communications office. “At this time, we do not yet know how many matches will be held in each city.”  

There is a lot that the public does not know about the 2026 tournament. In response to a freedom of information request for B.C.’s hosting proposal to FIFA, B.C. Pavilion Corporation withheld almost all 117 pages. The taxpayer-owned stadium operator cited exceptions to the public records law that protect policy advice or recommendations, intergovernmental relations or negotiations, financial or economic interests of a public body, and business interests of a third party.

The only information visible includes Ministry and PavCo letterhead, PavCo CEO Ken Cretney’s signature, the words “table of contents” and “introduction,” and nine pages with “Vancouver Questionnaire” at the top.

PavCo budgeted $30,000 to send three employees to Qatar for FIFA’s Qatar 2022 observer programs, while Vancouver city hall budgeted $25,000 to send one Sport Hosting Vancouver employee and two Vancouver Police officers.

Vancouver Mayor Ken Sim went to Qatar to watch the World Cup on a personal vacation booked before he won the mayoralty. City hall has refused to release his daily calendar for now, citing a section of the law that allows it to delay by up to 60 business days the release of information that it intends to publish.  

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin A former member of the Vancouver

Bob Mackin

TransLink’s vaccine mandate is over. 

A Nov. 28 staff memo announced the mandatory vaccination policy is suspended effective Thursday for all workers, contractors and visitors of B.C. Rapid Transit Company, West Coast Express, TransLink, Coast Mountain Bus Company and Metro Vancouver Transit Police.

TransLink’s Sany Zein

“Proof of vaccination against COVID-19 will no longer be required and employees who are currently on an unpaid leave of absence will be invited back to the workplace,” said the memo from BCRTC president Sany Zein. “Additionally, new employees hired after Dec. 1 will not be required to declare their vaccination status.”

The policy had been subject to “ongoing re-evaluation since its implementation.” TransLink pledged to continue to monitor provincial health guidelines, but isn’t closing the door on reinstating a vaccine requirement.  

“As federal and provincial restrictions continue to ease, we believe suspending our policy at this time is the right decision. Rest assured this decision was not made lightly.”

Employees on leave of absence due to refusing vaccination must declare their intent to return to work by Dec. 23, but are eligible to return Dec. 1. The memo said incumbent workers are entitled to return to their prior role or an equivalent role. 

“The topic of COVID-19 vaccination is a difficult one, but no matter your vaccination status,

everyone deserves to be treated with respect. It is important that we are all committed to

creating a respectful, kind, and considerate workplace, irrespective of your colleagues’ choices.”

TransLink also reiterated that employees still seeking vaccinations will receive up to three consecutive hours of paid leave for each dose, as per the Employment Standards Act.

Each TransLink division maintains a communicable disease prevention plan, which still calls for employees and contractors to conduct a self-assessment before coming to work, and to not enter the workplace if feeling unwell, even with mild symptoms.

Nanaimo SkyTrain Station (Google)

BCRTC, however, maintains a self-isolation policy, despite Provincial Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry’s Nov. 17 announcement that the infected must quarantine. TransLink’s occupational health office will no longer require employees provide notification of a positive test.

The FAQ also emphasized employees are allowed to take up to three consecutive hours of paid leave for each COVID-19 vaccine dose, under the Employment Standards Act. 

“Please keep in mind that BCRTC operates an essential service for Metro Vancouver and employees are encouraged to schedule vaccination appointments while off-shift,” said the document. 

The change in policy coincides with the TransLink board’s last scheduled meeting of 2022 on Dec. 1. A report from CEO Kevin Quinn says that ridership reached 76.2% of pre-pandemic levels during the first week of November. Weekend ridership is growing faster than weekdays, because many downtown Vancouver workers are continuing to spend some or all of their time working from home. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin TransLink’s vaccine mandate is over.  A Nov.

Bob Mackin

The all-party committee that oversees Legislative Assembly operations voted Nov. 28 to amend communication rules for constituency offices, but the policies remain subject to the honour system.

Red carpet and snow shovel ready for the Lieutenant-Governor’s arrival at the Legislature on throne speech day, Feb. 12, 2019 (Mackin)

A report to the Legislative Assembly Management Committee (LAMC) from a subcommittee that meets behind closed doors said MLAs are personally liable for the cost of any communications deemed ineligible. But there is no enforcement regime, because MLAs decided it is up to each MLA and their staff to ensure they follow the Members’ Guide to Policy and Resources.

“MLAs are not allowed to print, mail, publish or distribute at the expense of the Legislative Assembly, any material seeking financial support or containing any identification or information of a partisan or political nature,” said the briefing note for the first LAMC meeting since August. “Constituency office communications cannot include political party or caucus logos/branding.” 

The briefing note indicated that members of the subcommittee on administration and operations “did not want an attestation form included in this process or for a scrutiny role to be undertaken by Legislative Assembly staff.”

It said the role of the Legislature’s financial services department is not to review and approve constituency office communications, but it may provide guidance on request about the content of proposed communications. 

The eligibility policy added advertising — including the MLA’s name and contact information — on benches, billboards, buses and at arena ice rinks. 

The ineligible communications list mentions party slogans, political statements, or other identifiers (excluding names and colours) and content that disparages any party or member.

Bowinn Ma models her branded mask (Twitter)

“Must not include negative comments or criticize another Member, caucus, or party’s policies, platforms, or actions,” it said.  

Ineligible communications also include soliciting donations (such as scholarships) in any form for any group or individual. Members may still encourage constituents to donate generally to food banks or other categories of charities.  

Right before the snap 2020 election, NDP MLAs went on a spending spree, using taxpayer funds to bolster their profile in the weeks and days leading to the Legislature’s dissolution. Nineteen MLAs combined for almost $145,000 to mail out letters, leaflets and postcards from their riding office budgets. 

Vancouver-Fraserview MLA George Chow expensed $10,269 for six transit shelter ads beginning the week before John Horgan called the election. Bowinn Ma (North Vancouver-Lonsdale) spent almost $19,000 to buy 5,000 non-medical cloth facemasks bearing her name and riding from Dad’s Printing. Delta North’s Ravi Kahlon spent almost $12,000 from the same supplier on 4,000 masks promoting his office.  

During the April 1 to June 30 quarter, MLAs spent a combined $249,248 on communications and advertising. Peace River South BC Liberal MLA Mike Bernier topped the list at $16,996.

MLAs also spent a combined $2.15 million on office administration for the quarter. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin The all-party committee that oversees Legislative

Bob Mackin

Two Richmond politicians joined China’s top local diplomat at a Nov. 22 ceremony for the swearing-in of a board affiliated with the Chinese Communist Party.

Consul-General Yang Shu (left) with MP Parm Bains and Coun. Alexa Loo (Phoenix TV)

Liberal MP Parm Bains (Steveston-Richmond East) and Richmond Coun. Alexa Loo sat in the front row of the Canadian Alliance of Chinese Associations (CACA) event with People’s Republic of China Consul-General Yang Shu. Bains and Loo also spoke from a podium at the event, according to a report by Phoenix TV, an outlet associated with the government in Beijing. 

“They’ve been contributing in a number of ways with charitable causes,” Bains said on the Phoenix TV report. “We’ve had several, not only natural disasters, but a pandemic we went through.”

The event was the inauguration ceremony of the 9th executive team of CACA, a Richmond-based umbrella for more than 100 business and cultural groups whose website states that it is in active participant in Overseas Chinese Affairs Office (OCAO) activities. OCAO is an arm of the CCP’s United Front program. A 2019 report from the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians warned that one of the United Front’s aims is to influence foreign politicians to adopt pro-China positions. 

The consulate’s Chinese website said Yang reiterated the goals of the recent CCP 20th national congress and expressed hope that new executive chair Xue Xiaomei and the rest of CACA would continue to support their ancestral country’s economic and social development. It also said Xue mentioned support for reunification of China, a reference to Xi Jinping’s goal of taking control of Taiwan.

Consul-General Yang Shu at the CACA board event (PRC Consulate)

Neither Bains nor Loo responded to interview requests. Richmond Coun. Kash Heed, a former B.C. Solicitor General and police chief, said politicians at every level of government need to be cautious of foreign influence attempts.

“Local government representatives get invitations from all types of organizations throughout the Lower Mainland. It’s incumbent upon any of these elected members to do their due diligence, to ensure they’re not caught up in any other foreign influence political moves,” Heed said. 

Prior to her recent re-election, Loo joined Yang outside the Vancouver Art Gallery at a culture festival on Oct. 1, to celebrate the 73rd anniversary of CCP rule in China. 

In January, Bains and fellow Liberal MPs Taleeb Noormohamed (Vancouver Granville) and Wilson Miao (Richmond Centre) attended a private lunar new year event in Chinatown where then-Consul-General Tong Xiaoling promoted the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics. In December 2021, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced Canada joined an international boycott of Beijing 2022 over the treatment of Uyghur Muslims and other human rights abuses.

A statement released by Bains’s office after the Chinatown event said that he believed “open dialogue is more helpful” in dealing with China.

“I will continue to share and promote Canadian values and be a vocal advocate for human rights with all diplomats that are stationed here in Canada,” said Bains.

However, he subsequently admitted that he did not discuss human rights with Tong.

“The fact that local politicians are really dancing to the tune of China’s senior official in the region is, to my mind, just unconscionable and it should not happen,” said David Mulroney, former Canadian ambassador to China, in a February interview. “There should be Canadian solidarity on issues around human rights.”

Nanaimo Mayor Leonard Krog (left) with China’s Vancouver Consul-General Yang Shu (PRC Consulate)

The CACA board swearing-in came after Trudeau’s tense sidelines meeting with Xi at the G20 summit in Bali and a Global News report that CSIS warned Trudeau last January that the Chinese government meddled in the 2019 federal election. 

Three weeks after the original Global report, Trudeau claimed he knew nothing about Chinese government-funded campaigns. 

In the 2021 election, Bains beat Conservative incumbent Kenny Chiu, who had been targeted by a Chinese social media disinformation campaign after proposing a foreign agents registry and being sanctioned for voting to declare China’s treatment of Uyghurs a genocide.

Meanwhile, on November 17, Yang visited Nanaimo Mayor Leonard Krog. 

The consulate’s Chinese website said that Yang congratulated Krog on his re-election. A photo showed Krog, holding a facemask, standing next to Yang, with more than four consulate-branded gift bags on a table behind them. 

“The two sides exchanged views on jointly promoting local exchanges and cooperation between China and Canada,” said the consular website. 

Krog did not respond for comment. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin Two Richmond politicians joined China’s top

Bob Mackin

Protests against China’s strict “zero COVID” policy and the Chinese Communist Party government spread to Vancouver on Nov. 27. 

Around 200 people gathered on the Vancouver Art Gallery’s north plaza for a candlelight vigil for the Uyghur victims of a Nov. 24 apartment fire in Urumqi, capital of China’s northwestern Xinjiang province. At least 10 people died when firefighters and equipment could not reach them in time. It became the tipping point for anger that has simmered for weeks over pandemic lockdowns, including mass-protests at the Foxconn iPhone factory in Zhengzhou.

From the Nov. 27 candlelight vigil outside VAG (Mackin)

On the rainy Vancouver night, flowers and lit candles were strewn across the art gallery’s steps, with portraits of some of the Urumqi fire victims interspersed with messages in Chinese and English, urging Xi Jinping to resign and echoing the “give me liberty or give me death” phrase. Winnie the Pooh dolls were propped-up, back-to-back on a table, representing an unflattering caricature of Xi. One poster overlaid the Nazi swastika on the Chinese Communist Party’s hammer and sickle and mocked the party’s “serve the people” slogan.

People waved replicas of the sign Wulumqi Road sign. So named for the Xinjiang capital, the Shanghai street became the rallying point for protesters on Saturday. 

Speakers on a portable sound system led the Vancouver crowd in song and slogan, repeating phrases heard throughout the weekend in social media clips from Chinese street protests. Some speakers also expressed support for Tibetans, feminists and LGBTQ people.

Recently elected ABC Vancouver Coun. Lenny Zhou Tweeted photos he shot after the protest, including a selfie beside a replica of the street sign on a silent protester’s tablet. 

“In memory of all those who lost their lives due to the zero COVID policy. Appreciate everyone who attended the commemoration event tonight at [VAG], even with the wind and rain. The light of [candles] won’t go out!” Tweeted Zhou, who originally came from Beijing to Vancouver as a student in 2005.

A few protesters waved Republic of China flags. One student explained he is not Taiwanese, but that he is against communism and believes the true government of China fled to Taiwan in 1949. He exchanged words briefly with a bigger group which had a smaller version of the People’s Republic of China’s five-star flag. The Vancouver Police officers parked on Howe Street were not needed.

Vancouver Coun. Lenny Zhou of ABC after the protest on Nov. 27 (Twitter/LennyNanZhou)

Afterward, an elderly man moved a flyer from the art gallery wall to a lamp post at Georgia and Howe. It urged support for Uyghurs, Tibetans, Hong Kongers, Taiwanese and Ukrainians, to “stand with all the peoples resisting dictatorship, oppression and violence.” 

The man declined to give his name, but said he was originally from Hong Kong and encouraged by the youth of the crowd. “This is a good sign for us,” he said.

Andrew, who did not want his full name published, was the man holding the tablet from Zhou’s selfie.

“Although I’ve been a Canadian for a very long time, I still have my Chinese heritage, my family is still Chinese and I believe I should be here and to show support, show solidarity with my own people,” he said. “To show that even if this road sign was removed in Shanghai, that it will pop up worldwide in any city, as long as people stand with democracy, stand with sensible humanity.” 

The protests across China recall the student uprising in the spring of 1989, which ended with the Tiananmen Square massacre. Andrew, who said he studied political science, worries that history could repeat. He also called the students who came to protest outside VAG courageous. 

“There’s a very real chance that people are putting their security at stake, because first of all, many of them, the international students, have family in China. Time and again, it has been shown that the CCP will make problems and will warn their family members, so that they can stop their protests overseas.”

In the 1970s, the Chinese government created the Chinese Students and Scholars Association (CSSA), which has affiliates on university and college campuses around B.C. A 2020 report by the U.S. State Department said the CSSA is overseen by the United Front Work Department to “monitor Chinese students and mobilize them against views that dissent from the CCP’s stance.”

Nobody from the CSSA chapter at the University of B.C. responded for comment.

From the Nov. 27 candlelight vigil outside VAG (Mackin)

The mood Sunday night was in stark contrast to the heated August 2019 protests by Chinese nationalist students in various cities, including Vancouver, to counter pro-democracy demonstrations in support of Hong Kongers. 

Local protests took place outside the Broadway City Hall Canada Line station, on the Granville Mall, outside the Chinese consulate and Tenth Church, where the Hong Kong protesters held a prayer vigil. Some of the nationalists even waved Chinese flags in a parade of supercars. The Canada Vancouver Shanxi Natives Society later took responsibility for organizing the nationalist protests. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin Protests against China’s strict “zero COVID”

Bob Mackin

When Canada finally returned to the FIFA World Cup in Qatar with a narrow 1-0 loss to number two-ranked Belgium, it didn’t look like a team that lost an opportunity to play a key warm-up match.

Back in June, players staged a strike that scuttled a friendly against Panama, the replacement for the cancelled B.C. Place Stadium meeting with World Cup-bound Iran. The Canadian Soccer Association had not agreed to share the Qatar 2022 appearance money of at least $10 million. Players wanted 40% of the sum, travel, accommodation and tickets to Qatar for friends and family and pay equity for the women’s team. CSA president Nick Bontis dismissed the players’ demands as “untenable.”

Canada’s men’s national team in 2022 (CSA)

The squad was shocked to learn that the CSA had virtually given away most of its marketing rights to Canadian Soccer Business, a private entity behind the Canadian Premier League and the OneSoccer streaming service.  

Bontis said in a Nov. 9 webcast with the National Soccer Coaches Association of Canada that the CSA was nearing an equitable deal with players on both the men’s and women’s teams and many of their concerns were being addressed. 

North Vancouver lawyer Ron Perrick represented the players the first time Canada qualified for the World Cup, at Mexico 1986. For him, history was repeating. 

“The controversy was a result of the CSA not getting their ducks in a row and getting some aggressive marketing out there for the players,” Perrick said. “I mean, the only player that we were hearing about was [Alphonso] Davies. We didn’t hear a lot about all the other players. There was no profile.”

Perrick felt the CSA should have bargained fairly and openly with the players as soon as they finished as the top qualifier from the North and Central American and Caribbean (CONCACAF) zone in March. Especially since they automatically qualify for 2026 when Vancouver and Toronto are among the host cities.

(FIFA/CSA)

“This tournament [in Qatar] will set the table for the next one, and a lot of these players will be around and then that’ll give the incentive for a lot of other young players to want to get on that team and it should snowball in the right direction,” he said. 

It came down to the wire 36 years ago. A month before Canada debuted at Mexico 1986, Perrick reached a deal with the CSA that included training camp per diems, $1,500 per game per player, and a percentage of the CSA’s receipts from FIFA. “If the CSA does well, the players will do well,” Perrick said at the time.

The deal came after Molson Breweries put up a half-million dollars for the players, who were playing in a post-North American Soccer League environment in Europe, the Major Indoor Soccer League and even in domestic senior men’s leagues. CSA chief operating officer Kevan Pipe balked. 

“We locked horns,” Perrick recalled. “I came to a deal and what we did is we shared it, and then each player was allowed to go out and get his own sponsorships, and he could retain the money for that. As a collective group, we would split the money up with that, and we would share with the CSA and they would share with us.” 

Friendlies in Vancouver against Wales and Burnaby against England went ahead. The team lost its matches in Mexico against the Soviet Union, France and Hungary.

After failing to qualify for Italy 1990, the stakes were high for 1994, when the tournament was going to be next door in the U.S. CSA secretly sold the rights for a Toronto qualifier against Mexico to the owner of the Toronto Blizzard for $100,000 and let him keep proceeds from the gate receipts. Perrick continued to negotiate with Pipe as Canada prepared for a match in Edmonton against Australia at the end of July 1993, the first of a home-and-home series for a wildcard berth in USA 1994. Perrick and Pipe didn’t reach a deal. 

“We didn’t say strike, we just weren’t going to play,” Perrick said. 

Perrick left his Edmonton hotel to return to Vancouver. On the way out, he stopped for a drink and a chat with Jim Taylor in the lounge. The legendary sports columnist later told a radio show the game wasn’t going to happen. 

“That caused a lot of excitement,” Perrick said. “By the time I got back to Vancouver, into my house, we had a deal. It was a good one for the players and when the Australian guys found out what the Canadian players were making, when they had the return match back in Australia, they went on strike. It was pretty funny actually.”

CBC SportsWeekend (CBC)

Perrick negotiated for the players to receive $1,750 per game and $250 per point. They would have received a $5,000 had they advanced to the 1994 tournament.

Canada did play in the U.S., albeit more than six years later when they won the 2000 CONCACAF Gold Cup in Los Angeles. It was the men’s national team’s biggest achievement prior to 2022. Perrick negotiated for the players to receive $3,000 for a win, $2,500 for a tie, $2,000 for a loss, whether they were on the pitch or on the bench. 

Since then, soccer has grown in Canada, through Major League Soccer’s expansion, recruitment of Canadian players by top European teams, and TV and streaming deals that showcase the best teams and players.

“Everybody should get rewarded, and if you’ve got smart people or good people in the marketing positions, the sky’s really the limit, and it should be,” Perrick said. 

Support theBreaker.news for as low as $2 a month on Patreon. Find out how. Click here.

Bob Mackin When Canada finally returned to the